Dr. Scott Brannan’s office.
“I’m in a lot of pain,” Brannan recalls. I don’t think I can do it. “
The patient in his sixties, Brannan said, slept in a recliner because when he went to bed, his legs were cramped.
Brannan called.
He under pressure that the bad scenario.
The patient had to enter from a distance.
Then Brannan jumped into his minivan, a Dodge Caravan with license plate: WIREDOC.
He drove to the boy’s home in Gold Canyon, just outside the Phoenix subway. Brannan took the patient to his clinic and did his job, and then took him to the boy’s house.
Brannan is an interventional radiologist. He threads angel hair through the arteries of one leg to probe the body’s pipes and clean the hooves, down to some of the smaller vessels near the toes.
Brannan has picked up patients from their homes. It’s an unorthodox practice that he says is motivated by compassion. You need your staff to see a doctor who performs humble tasks.
However, a former employee saw him as Brannan to pack as many surgeries as he could.
The former employee’s skepticism is reflected in seven lawsuits filed against the corporation Brannan works for and in interviews with current and former members. They describe a search for profit that questions the alleged altruistic project of the chain of clinics where Brannan has become famous. : Modern vascular.
Brannan’s enthusiasm propelled him from a trailer to medical school, from repeated arrests to national notoriety. Its turnover exploded in the five years that Modern Vascular expanded from the Phoenix metro area to 17 locations in 10 states.
The company aims to save you amputations. But Modern Vascular is plagued by allegations, some in lawsuits, that its speculation technique has caused injuries and deaths after surgeries.
Modern Vascular is based on the vulnerabilities of American healthcare, where the pursuit of profit calls for a doctor’s natural commitment to patients under the Hippocratic oath. The company solicited investments from the reference podiatrists and paid them dividends. It collected six-figure discounts from a device, developed a strategy to opt for a billing code to generate revenue and, at least at one clinic, pushed for a portion of patients who came in for an intervention, according to corporate documents and court records reviewed across the Republic of Arizona.
Modern Vascular claims that its clinics have performed thousands of procedures and that their complication rate is low. When asked, the company did not provide any data upon request.
It would possibly not be imaginable to quantify the consequences of Modern Vasculcular’s lucrative technique or compare its complication rate with its peers, as injuries during procedures in vascular clinics like yours do not want to be tracked independently.
Brannan detailed how exceptional he and his company are, adding a case where they did pro bono work. But he also said health care is governed by amoral market mechanisms.
“Most of the public doesn’t know to what extent all medicine is a business,” Brannan said.
He will tell his loved ones to resist his doctors’ referrals to specialists for exotic procedures, he said.
“In most cases, I tell my family, or I tell friends who accept as true to me, please don’t do it,” Brannan said. “Please don’t take this path. This is how the formula works: it is legitimized because there are certifications and a rigorous educational procedure that surrounds it. You’re advertised in a lot of titles right now, whether you know it or not.
Victoria Garcia lost a leg after an operation through Brannan. But he pumped his biceps for her and then convinced her to have another one, she said. Garcia’s attorney provided a copy of a lawsuit she said she filed Monday. the company charged more than $300,000 and performed “unnecessary and medically misplaced vascular procedures that caused Ms. Garcia to lose her remaining leg after an amputation. “
The vascular surgeon who amputated Garcia’s momentary leg, Dr. Brett Siegrist, told The Republic he didn’t want Brannan’s momentary surgery.
“I expect to see headaches in my practice similar to other doctors’ vascular procedures,” Siegrist said. “I can say there are too many that come from Modern Vascular. “
Garcia is already home.
“I’m going to bed, I cross my legs, well, my stumps,” he said, “and I’m going to go there and cry. “
“Every time there’s an amputation, it’s a huge loss, for the patient and for me,” Brannan said of Garcia. “I feel like it’s a failure. But there are some, unfortunately, there are still some cases that take place again, and I don’t know exactly why they take place.
Much of Brannan’s life is documented in court records and police reports. His career and appointments with Modern Vascular are informed through lawsuits and described through patients, Brannan’s peers, current and former Modern Vascular employees, senior management, and more than 16 hours of interviews with Brannan.
He is intelligent, charismatic and erratic.
Publicly, he boasted:
“I’ve done more of it than on earth,” Brannan said in an interview.
But when he looked at his image reflected in the bathroom mirror, his ex-wife told the court, he tore:
“I hate you! Fuck, I hate you!”
Temporarily moving even when he was lost, Brannan saw the prison, a Paradise Valley mansion, and a glimpse of his own doom:
“When I die,” he once wrote, “it has been revealed to me, I will pass to hell because of the possible choices I made. “
Brannan and others at Modern Vascular primarily treat a narrowing of blood vessels called “peripheral artery disease,” which affects other people with diabetes and former smokers. They market their paintings as modern, smaller versions of familiar equipment to succeed in the tiny blood vessels of the feet.
A skilled doctor may feel sophisticated resistance in the thread. It’s like running a thread through the 20-needle chassis. Too much tension or haste and the thread can rupture the artery.
A doctor’s mistake can cost a patient his leg or his life. Therefore, surgery is only worth acting when the potential benefits outweigh the risks. For example, surgery may be warranted if someone feels pain even when they’re not walking, one expert explained. , or if they have a foot injury that is rarely very healing.
Brannan said he was smart at his craft because he had so much fun stemming from an “irrational expectation of perfection. “
“I stay when others prevent it sometimes,” he said.
Brannan ranks seventh among more than 1,600 doctors who bill for procedures, according to public Medicare data. Three other fashionable vascular doctors also rank very well.
“The knowledge suggests that the company encourages billing best practices and that at least some of its doctors practice them,” said Dr. Brown. Caitlin Hicks, an associate professor of surgery at Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine who has studied the overuse of vascular interventions. He said he observed patterns of overuse in his knowledge.
Brannan and other trendy vascular doctors may rank first because their companies champion invasive procedures over conservative treatments, which wastes public money and puts patients at risk, according to a lawsuit alleging fraud filed in 2020. This demand and two other similar movements were kept under control. they sealed until they came together in September through the Justice Department. One of those claimed government systems paid millions for procedures through Modern Vascular.
“We’re doing a job,” Modern Vascular founder and president Yury Gampel said when the fraud lawsuit was made public. “We save members every day at all of our clinics. “
The branch investigated Modern Vascular for at least a year, up to a Q.
In addition to the lawsuits filed by the Department of Justice, 11 lawsuits filed on behalf of patients detail allegations of harm to modern vascular patients. Five other people said they were injured in interviews with The Republic.
At least four other people have lost members, two of whom have sued. Two modern vascular patients have lost their lives, according to the lawsuits. At least five patients have claimed in lawsuits that the procedures were not necessary.
Nine of the 11 lawsuits were still open as of Oct. 3, and Modern Vascular dismissed the claims in court. One case was settled under confidential conditions, according to a lawyer who sued a fashionable vascular doctor. An attorney said he dismissed his lawsuit similar to the death of a fashionable vascular patient because no toxicological investigation was conducted on the patient.
At least 3 other people were injured in Brannan’s custody, according to the prosecution’s indictments. Two of his cases were ongoing and Brannan denied all claims in court. The other cases have been resolved, Brannan said.
At a former clinic where Brannan worked, one of his patients died, according to court documents and testimony before the Arizona Medical Board. Faced with a negligence claim, Brannan described in a statement that he paid the patient’s daughter in installments totaling $10,000.
Arizona’s trendy vascular clinics have been cited statewide 23 times for issues such as lack of quality control, non-rejection of expired medications and lack of proper documentation of a patient’s death two days after a trendy vascular procedure, according to state records. Records show that clinics have come up with plans to correct the problems.
Sometimes, when modern vascular patients have problems, call 911. The company says this is a common practice. They did so at least 30 times in clinics in five cities, according to recordings of emergency calls to their addresses. That includes a patient who emergency services discovered “bleeding” in the Tucson operating room.
Glendale vascular surgeon David Terry claimed in one of the pending lawsuits filed through the Justice Department that Modern Vascular’ Glendale Clinic “has engaged in a trend of patient procedures. “
One bedridden patient died as a result of a procedure performed through Brannan, according to the lawsuit.
“They’re a risk to this community,” Terry said in an interview.
Brannan hiding in his room. He closed the door. A flash of visceral worry passed him.
A hearing before the Arizona Medical Board went wrong, then won an email from a reporter asking him to communicate about his life, divorce, lawsuits and criminal record.
His corporate lawyer told him to speak up.
But he didn’t let that stop him.
Among the first things he said, after leaving his shelter to answer for his past: “I color the lines well outdoors. “
To find out who he is, Brannan presented a tour of his humble hometown. He whipped his white Chevy Suburban north of Scottsdale, a reporter with a shotgun.
He told his life story, admitted some mistakes, and hoped that his most productive qualities would redeem him. He texted and received calls while driving. He apologized loudly to the horns he cut. It has a big blind spot.
As for the issues with the Arizona Medical Board, he said, we’ll get back on that later.
Five feet 103/4 inches tall, weighing 209 pounds with a length of 34 inches. He has no military training, but he has army weapons. He was wearing a tight gray T-shirt with an American flag stretched out on his right shoulder. He said he had been taking Ritalin or Adderall since high school and stepped forward with the help of anabolic steroids.
Brannan describes himself as a poor country boy. He said he had long struggled with a feeling of illegitimacy eating away at him. He exceeded expectations and also exaggerated his achievements.
“I got a degree, two degrees, from Yale, a degree from Harvard,” he said, exaggerating the fact of his residency and scholarship.
As a child, Brannan was crammed into a giant caravan of bachelors with his mother, 3 siblings and a cousin. They lived on the outskirts of Cottonwood, near a bend in the Green River, “my river,” Brannan says. The patch of vegetation shoots from Arizona dust about two hours north of Phoenix.
Brannan space located on an unnamed dirt road. Visitors discovered it through the landmarks of the farm animal guard.
Brannan and his siblings learned every inch of their river, swimming, hunting, fishing and catching. He still knows the smell of creosote flowers after the rain. He still knows his neighbor, who still lives in the trailer across the street.
As a child, Brannan watched him argue bitterly. He said one night his father tried to pull his mother’s tires as she drove away.
Alcohol and abuse led to a painful divorce, according to court records. When he was about 10 years old, his mother married a drug addict. He pushed her and threatened the children. When Brannan intervened, he fought against himself, as a court record shows.
Their mother kept them afloat with restaurant jobs. Sometimes, she discovered herself, and the strength was cut off. Her children wore freshly ironed Goodwill clothes.
Brannan was assigned his first task at age 12, washing dishes at a place to eat called Paragon. At 14, he drank until he fainted and woke up injured. He smoked weed and then used cocaine and methamphetamine, according to court records.
In high school, the blond, blue-eyed athlete made his mark on soccer, tennis, and golf. He helped with his family’s screen printing business. He struggled to keep up with all his classes, but managed to graduate with honors.
At age 17 he enrolled in an exchange program in Denmark. There he said he played football, ate well, had two cycles of anabolic steroids, came back surprised and found jobs as a private coach.
Brannan discovered a position under the wing of Dr. Thomas Peters, a wealthy orthopedic surgeon from Cottonwood who treated Brannan’s bad knees while playing sports in high school. Peters married Brannan’s mother.
His new stepfather represented security: Brannan didn’t have to worry about his mother going broke. He didn’t have to charge school fees or worry about a wonderful car arrangement ruining him. He went into the operating room with Peters and thought of systems for a nurse or a surgical technician.
“Why do you need to be a surgeon?” recalled telling Peters, pushing him to aim higher.
By 19, Brannan had reconciled with his biological father, who had stopped drinking. He stayed with his father in Tempe and enrolled in a pre-med program at Mesa Community College, hoping to attend Arizona State University. His father was bright and kind, he later wrote.
But “aggressive”.
Brannan suspected her friend was with another man, according to court records. He said it was a “bad ass. ” So Brannan put his father’s loaded Array38 caliber revolver in his pocket and went to Christopher Dempsey’s house.
He saw his girlfriend’s car at Dempsey’s. He tried to “catch them red-handed,” the court record says.
Brannan kicked the front door, looking to break it.
Dempsey pounced on Brannan and punched him in the face. Brannan pulled out the gun, hit Dempsey with it, and fired close to Dempsey’s head.
Brannan fled and when he was temporarily arrested, he heard on the police radio that Dempsey was wounded, but the bullet had not worked.
“Damn it,” Brannan said, according to a court filing, “I shot him. “
He accused Brannan of annoying assault, which can mean prison time.
It was cleaned for the court. Well kept. Big ambitions. He presented “the symbol of the American boy next door. “
He gave $5,000 to Dempsey, who said Brannan was not the aggressor and that “his moves were committed in self-defense in a mutual fight. “
“He came into my space with a gun to break down my door and I kicked his ass,” Dempsey said in a text message to The Republic. “He knows. “
Brannan’s father and stepfather wrote letters to pass judgment on his promising future.
He pleaded guilty to a reduced rate of damage by thieves. The sentence handed down gave him parole, which ended at age 22.
Brannan enrolled in ASU and connected with other academics to chart a path to medical school. The next step: the medical school admission test, or MCAT.
Brannan has solved a lot of problems, but for a long time he had struggled to feel like an impostor.
“Every time I do something great, I feel like they’re going to understand,” he said in an interview, “and I put each and every one in their place, and it gets even worse, and every time I progress, every time I progress, all that is done is to motivate the hope of each and every one, so that when they see who I am, even if it’s a disaster.
At the same time, the MCAT is a stand-alone measure.
“You can’t idiotize that,” he thought Brannan. De no way can you idiotize the living room and customize your way through the MCAT. “
He killed him.
He won a letter of acceptance for medicine at the University of Arizona and cried at the post office.
“I’m an imposter and they let me do it,” he thought. I’m going to let you all down when you find out who I am. “
Within a week, he was handcuffed.
He had been involved in a national marijuana smuggling ring. With favors for his roommate asu, he said. Like: Go buy boxes. And then: Hey, listen, can you weigh five pounds and put it in a box?And then: Could you record that? I’ll give you two hundred dollars.
“I knowingly contributed to my downfall,” Brannan now says.
He remembers sitting outside the Scottsdale hideout. A police car stopped.
Soon handcuffed him, a black Yukon shouted around the corner, and an officer jumped up, the badge hanging from a chain: “DEA!”
They discovered 900 pounds of marijuana: 121 bricks topped with air fresheners stacked in a bedroom window, five bullets in the kitchen, seven bullets in a garage next to the indifferent garage. A bullet, Brannan explained, is five to 20 pounds of marijuana, flattened into a rectangle and rolled like hay in a field.
Police also discovered steroids in Brannan’s car. Brannan, her former roommate, her friend and another guy were arrested.
He sobbed at his father: “My life is over, Dad.
As his case progressed in court, Brannan went to medicine at the University of Arizona. During the orientation, he informed management about his recent arrest.
“You have to know that this is not a case of the place, at that time,” Brannan said. “I’m not a baby in the forest. I knew what was going on. I knew my roommate was trafficking marijuana or promoting marijuana and I knowingly committed acts as part of his criminal activity.
They were alarmed but let him stay. He had to see a psychiatrist and assist in 12 steps.
“First of all, I dismissed him as a wayward muscleman,” a classmate later wrote.
Then Brannan ascended to the most sensible in his class.
During his junior year of school, Brannan said he scored exceptionally well on the first component of a standardized check to a licensed physician. An idol, Dr. Harlan Stone, ruled it out. ” Scott, we want to formulate a plan for your future surgery. “
Finally, everything came here together. It has been independently verified. He felt joy and fullness without mixing.
Then he went to court.
The deputy prosecutor in the Brannan case intended to hammer him.
But Brannan was recommended by A. Melvin “Mel” McDonald, one of the state’s top lawyers.
Brannan said that through contacts in the structures industry, his mother put him in touch with McDonald, a former federal prosecutor who is an assistant district attorney for Maricopa County and a Superior Court judge. Brannan said he had recently finished paying McDonald’s fees at $1,000 per month. They are in touch to this day, Brannan said, close to the most productive friends.
“He went to paints with a hammer and pliers with the county prosecutor’s office,” Brannan said.
The ruling declined to meet “informally” to discuss Brannan’s case. But McDonald carried out a clever maneuver, convincing the county’s highest-ranking prosecutor to overturn the resolution of the deputy prosecutor handling Brannan’s case.
Brannan and his co-defendants closed deals that prompted skeptical comments of a judgment passed in a friend’s case: Those white defendants were getting “too smart a deal,” according to a court document.
Brannan pleaded guilty to attempting to possess more than 4 pounds of marijuana for sale and cooperated with police investigating the drug trafficking ring, which stretched from Arizona to Massachusetts.
His plea sentences him to 8 and a quarter years in prison.
The sentence sentenced Brannon to 2 1/2 years.
After the conviction, McDonald’s went to an old-school Phoenix central steakhouse called Beef Eaters, he said. He looked across the room and saw Rose Mofford, a former governor who McDonald said had handed down a sentence on who convicted Brannan. He walked over, sat down and told her how devastated it was that Brannan went to jail.
“Well, if I can ever help,” he recalls, saying. And the duo, along with state Rep. Polly Rosenbaum, went to work.
In Florence prison, Brannan “Doc”.
As a white inmate, he caught the attention of the Aryan Brotherhood. They learned that he had cooperated with the police and fired a “torpedo,” a detainee seeking greater prestige within the gang. He hit Brannan with a padlock attached to a sock. It hurt, but Brannan was not hospitalized.
Brannan leaned over his prayer. Every day he woke up, put his feet on the ground and prayed, “Please, God, please let me be a doctor.
He attempted to attend medical school and begged the guards to increase his stipend through seven books at a time, for copies of “The Fountainhead,” “Siddhartha,” “Evolution of Desire,” and “The Mating Mind. “
He continually complained about detention situations, but in prominent terms:
“Recent menu adjustments have provoked widespread and excessive discontent, bordering on absolute anger. I’m sure of that. . . “
While Brannan pushed for more cable reception and pest control, his attorney convinced the state’s clemency board to replace a policy to review his case sooner.
“It didn’t hurt me to have been an incredible judge and an American lawyer,” McDonald said.
He then presented a Brannan clemency packet as thick as a phone book, which said who’s who of tough Arizonans. In addition to Mofford, McDonald was able to protect former Arizona governors Fife Symington, Evan Mecham and Raul Castro. .
And the aspiring medical student leaned on an old circle of family friends, Steve Twist, the state’s former deputy attorney general. Brannan said his father and Twist went to Camelback High School and served on the student council together.
Twist wrote a letter asking for brannan’s clemency to the Republic through Brannan’s lawyer.
“As the primary author of the legislation he violated, he would make that decision entirely,” Twist wrote.
Brannan went to the mercy council dressed in an orange jumpsuit, with the dolls chained to a chain around his belly, hooked to a chain around his ankles. It clinked in his ear.
In the gallery, he saw his former mentor, Dr. Stone. He spoke on Brannan’s behalf and said he had a long and brilliant career in medicine.
A few months later, guards put on her a pair of baggy jeans, made in prison, a cambray blouse with misaligned wallet, and engraved military blue shoes. They gave it to his father.
The clemency committee had taken into account Brannan’s harsh chorus. Governor Jane Hull signed a suspicious plea agreement in October 2002. Of the 572 cases reviewed by the council that year, Brannan among 12 other people (2 percent) whose sentences were reduced through the governor, according to a history of the Republic.
His co-defendants have served their full sentences.
A judgment ordered Brannan to pay a $102,000 fine for his drug case.
Brannan estimated he earned $20,000 from the drug operation. Through his attorney, he was able to increase his fine from the proposed six figures to $14,000, less than the proceeds of the crime.
Although he expressed his involvement, his lawyer convinced that a sentence be issued to dismiss his accusation.
To this day, he is obsessed through his police record.
“You feel like walking a tightrope,” he said. You need to reveal yourself to people, but there are things you hope they don’t know. “
Brannan was snatched from prison, but could not get back on track.
Brannan questioned before a committee at the University of Arizona but said he eventually agreed to a deal to separate from the school, taking credit for the educational paintings he had done so far.
He struggled to move to school in the United States, he said, so he looked abroad.
He accepted through Grace School of Medicine in Belmopan, Belize.
During the third and fourth years of his medical training, he enrolled remotely in a school in Central America, but spent his time alternating in American hospitals.
The school ceased to exist in Belize on the precise day of 2004, Brannan claims its start date. Brannan said the school did not need to pay a payment to continue operating in that country and that it had enough credits to graduate when the Belize campus closed.
A few years after Brannan discovered the school in Belize, the entrepreneur who would go on to launch Modern Vascular would move money to Panama.
Originally from Soviet Ukraine, Yury Gampel is a chiropractor in training. He has ties to a sprawling home in the upscale Los Angeles suburb of Calabasas, and a taste for the Amalfi Coast and George Michael. His empire included managing surgery centers, as well as holdings in RV parks and a rehabilitation corporation once cut off from Medicaid after an Arizona ruling decided it was a credible allegation of fraud.
Gampel and his wife sought the recommendation of Mossack Fonseca, a law firm infamous for hiding cash for the world and infamous, as revealed through a collection of millions of leaked documents known as the Panama Papers.
The documents were first shared with the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists and Süddeutsche Zeitung, and then with The Republic.
Gampel and his wife used Mossack Fonseca to start a business, according to the Panama Papers files. The company bought a condo at the Trump Ocean Club International Hotel and Tower, a luxurious sail-shaped oceanfront tower in Panama City believed to be connected to money laundering. The lawyers’ corporation allegedly shut down and its namesake founders were among those accused of crimes; Two members of Congress pressured the Trump Organization, which it controlled through Donald Trump, over allegations of money laundering, according to a news report.
Other people who invested in the construction included groomed criminal figures, according to reports. There David Murcia Guzman, who was convicted in the United States of laundering cash for drug cartels. Then there was Louis Pargioias, who pleaded guilty in Miami to conspiracy to import cocaine. And then there is Stanislav Kavalenka, accused in Canada of recruiting women into prostitution.
The Gampels’ contract, in which Yury Gampel’s call is crossed out and his wife’s is handwritten, guaranteed that for $571,500, their 938-square-foot “luxury” studio would be furnished and finished in marble and granite. They would take advantage of valet parking and, for $15,000 more, the building’s beach club.
In the end, Gampel bought 10 condos from the Trump Ocean Club, an email said.
“To purchase real estate in Panama, a client wants an established Panamanian entity to acquire the property,” a Gampel spokesperson wrote in an email. “In 2007, Mr. Gampel, investor in a Panamanian company called Orio Management. games of the Trump Ocean Club, which at that time was structured in Panama City. Mossack Fonseca served as Orio Management’s local registered agent and did not provide any other services. All appropriate and applicable disclosures were made in the United States and Panama.
It’s unclear what happened to the investment, however, the Panama Papers filing shows that Lampel’s company “canceled,” with an indexed “inactivation date” a few years before Modern Vascular’s launch.
Do you have any with Modern Vascular? Here’s how to get in touch
At least at several events where Brannan publicly described his education, he mentioned his defunct Belize medical school.
“I was fortunate enough to study at wonderful places on the East Coast, Yale University Hospital, Massachusetts General Hospital and Harvard Medical School,” he said in a radio interview.
His biography of Modern Vascular states that he “finished his studies at Yale University, Bridgeport Hospital. . . “
His biography at a convention in 2018 lists his credentials as “Residency: Yale University” and “Fellowship: Harvard Medical School, Vascular and Interventional Radiology. “
His registration with the Arizona Medical Board indicates that after graduating from the Belize School, he went to the “Internal Medicine Residency at Yale-Bridgeport University Hospital” in Connecticut. Bridgeport Hospital is a component of Yale New Haven’s physical care system, but is separate from Yale University, according to university spokeswoman Karen Peart. “Yale University Hospital” exists.
He earned a fellowship at Massachusetts General Hospital and added clinical education at Harvard Medical School, according to school spokeswoman Laura DeCoste. But she wrote in an email that it’s not correct for him to say he has a Harvard degree.
“Please note that Dr. Brannan is NOT a graduate of Harvard Medical School, and has no arrangement or arrangement with theArray,” a spokesperson wrote.
Brannan bristled when asked about the inconsistencies. He wrote in a text message that the guy who wrote his biography at the 2018 medical convention “is notoriously a layman and it’s definitely not me. “
He wrote that he entered Harvard Medical School.
“I have never deceived myself about my education,” he wrote. I’m very proud of the schooling and schooling I’ve received. “
Brannan married his current wife, Vera Assad Gebran, in Lebanon, months after divorcing his first wife. Brannan and Gebran have 4 children.
Brannan would argue in court that, despite his gigantic income, she had driven him to earn more. PC in a pool, he urinated on his clothes, hit a boy’s tennis racket so hard that it disintegrated, ripped the playroom door off its hinges, and closed the metal doors until they broke.
After Massachusetts, Brannan took on a job in Missouri, where he was fired “due to too many consecutive patient headaches and workplace hostility,” according to court documents filed through Gebran. He worked in Illinois, where he faced a lawsuit alleging he had ruptured a woman’s artery. Brannan said the case was settled for about $100,000.
Also in Illinois, he learned of a regulatory quirk that replaced his career.
Executes a concept for opening arteries in an outpatient setting. This means that instead of operating in a hospital, with large overhead and more control, you may only test blood vessels in a doctor’s office.
Brannan heard the rumor of an unusual billing code for Medicare, he would do so later in a court filing.
He went to a library, got on a PC and looked it up.
In fact, in 2011, Medicare especially increased the amount of money a doctor can charge to open an artery in the leg with a billing code that averages about $12,000 depending on the procedure performed in an office.
“It’s a very specialized little code, code 37229,” Brannan said under oath in a statement, “. . . Not many other people knew. “
The code underpinned a concept he said he introduced to an Illinois clinic.
Brannan’s wife would later claim in court that he left the state after being fired from a job and arrived in Arizona by moonlight. But according to Brannan, his practice was sold and he moved to Arizona’s Navajo reservation in hopes of cutting the amputations. The resume you provided shows several tasks in this period.
Through the paintings he made to help build health care facilities, his mother became president of the Navajo Hopi Health Foundation, Brannan explained. Upon his release from prison, Brannan pledged to serve vulnerable communities for free. For a time, he painted in Tuba City.
Brannan then teamed up with Dr. Joel Rainwater, an interventional radiologist who collects watches like Brannan with a Phoenix-based practice now called Comprehensive Comprehensive Care. Rainwater also ranks high in the country among doctors who charge Medicare, but Brannan has surpassed it.
Brannan brought his affinity to Native Americans, an organization more vulnerable to diabetes than any other race, according to the CDC. He would later describe building relationships with patients, adding members of the Navajo Nation, Colorado River Indian tribes, San Carlos Apache, Gila river indigenous community, and Salt River Pima-Maricopa Indian community.
Diabetes is a precursor to the situations Rainwater and Brannan treat, making it a rich target, and Brannan grew that component of the business “exponentially. “
But soon there are problems.
His tax records show he earned at least $300,000 a year those years, but he and his wife owed more than $80,000 in unpaid taxes.
A few months after joining the Rainwater store, Brannan was suspended from a nearby hospital with which they had been under contract “due to exaggerated errors in mapping and documentation,” Rainwater told the court.
Brannan questioned this claim in an interview that he had never lost his hospital privileges.
Because Brannan did not dictate what he did in 28 cases, thousands of dollars in fees were withheld, Rainwater wrote in an email that was later filed in court.
Some at the hospital were afraid to work with Brannan, Rainwater wrote in the same email. They said Brannan canceled his orders without communicating, unapproachable to discuss patient care and abrupt with staff.
“You are a doctor with otherworldly abilities,” Rainwater wrote. “I want you to solve those problems. “
Rainwater would claim in a lawsuit that Brannan used amphetamines and steroids and that they were given too close to a competitor in town: Modern Vascular. A letter submitted as part of the trial, which has since been resolved, says Brannan once left the scene after ordering to calm a patient.
Brannan accused Rainwater of “stealing all Native American patients for himself,” according to a court document filed in the case. Rainwater said the settlement involved either side admitting fault. Brannan’s lawyer said the terms of the settlement were confidential.
Brannan is reportedly taking legal action, alleging that Rainwater’s lawsuit made defamatory comments about him. Brannan later withdrew the lawsuit, according to court records.
The straw that broke the camel’s back in March 2017, when one of Brannan’s patients died.
“I had a complication with a patient,” Brannan later said in a statement, “in which she ended up wasting a lot of blood on the case. We made sure he stopped bleeding. I sent her to the hospital for a transfusion. It was fine. for two days. And then, in the afternoon of the day of the moment, he had a stroke and died.
Rainwater drives it away.
“I. . . I had begged, pleaded,” Brannan said, “I would do anything. Please let me, let me work. I have to work. “
At a restaurant in Woodland Hills, an upscale suburb of Los Angeles, the successful concept that became Modern Vascular was born, according to the account of a man who claims to have been involved in a lawsuit.
Zeetser says they solved the main points at a dinner in Encino. Then, Gampel ran away, Zeetser claims in the lawsuit. Gampel has denied Zeeser’s allegations in court and the lawsuit is ongoing.
“I haven’t had any involvement in this company since the beginning of 2018, in terms of decision-making,” Zeetser said. “I’m very disappointed with what he’s done with this company. “
Zeetser had run vascular centers in California. Su lawsuit claims he and Gampel agreed to share their expertise and relationships to build centers in Arizona and then across the country. They would share ownership and give 25% to the doctors who would invest with them.
The latter is important.
Modern Vascular wants patients to remain active, as clinics do.
They have marketed themselves. Brannan spoke on the radio, representatives gave the impression on local news channels and the company ran full-page classified ads on The Republic.
It is illegal to pay doctors for referrals; This is a bribe.
But Modern Vascular exploited a loophole: They hired referral doctors as investors. On paper, those doctors aren’t paid to send patients, they get dividends from the good fortune of the company they own.
“It was simply the best marriage for a lot of podiatrists, like shooting, why wouldn’t we have to invest in something that’s smart for our patients, but in the end we’d also get a little bit of anything?” said podiatrist Dr. Stuart. Randall Brower, who was among the first investors, said what he did was ethical.
The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, the Office of the Inspector General of the U. S. Department of Health and Human Services, and the Office of Inspector General. The U. S. Department of Justice (which oversees Medicare) and the Justice Department declined to say Modern Vascular is a legal settlement.
It can also be simply. According to a spokesperson for the U. S. Department of Health and Human Services’ Office of Inspector General. In the U. S. , certain physical care industry agreements that would result in recalls would likely be protected from prosecution under port regulations. It is unclear whether Modern Vascular has this protection, as the workplace may not check or deny whether it is eligible for safe harbor.
The company’s founder referred a reporter’s questions to a public relations company whose specialties are “crisis communications. “His representative, Tanner Kaufman, did not say whether Modern Vascular operates under a port agreement.
“To be clear, simply investing in a doctor in some other medical practice is not problematic or contrary to the law,” Kaufman wrote in an email.
Brower practiced podiatry for 18 years. Before Modern Vascular, he said, he didn’t have a smart position to send his patients to vascular care for the narrower parts of the legs.
He attended a presentation at Modern Vascular’s Glendale office, where Gampel and Brannan explained the benefits of the generation they were and the wealth investors can expect. Their hope was that in a few years they would sell the company and make a fortune, Brower said. .
He paid $7,500 for 400 shares, according to a contract he shared with The Republic. Modern Vascular sold shares in two ways: the guy Brower bought can be bought through doctors. Medical investors can be kicked out of the company, the contract says. , however, other investors may simply not.
When a podiatrist at Mesa stopped sending patients to Modern Vascular because he felt they were receiving poor care, Gampel “canceled” his stake in Modern Vascular and “forcibly” bought its stock, according to one of the lawsuits filed through the Justice Department.
Brower said he referred 20 patients per month to Modern Vascular and had his cash back in 3 months. He calculated that he earned $100,000 on his $7,500 investment.
Brower said he felt his patients were getting care. But he also felt pressure from Gampel to refer more.
He recalled investor calls in which Gampel reviewed reference numbers and that if medical investors sought Modern Vascular to succeed, they should send more patients.
“That’s why they looked for podiatrists to invest, because simply investing will naturally push you to use the service,” Brower explained.
Pressure for referrals has also been exerted in the ranks of Modern Vascular. The company’s marketing reps were tasked with encouraging referrals and knew which doctors were investors, according to Kenneth “Chip” Macdonald, a former fashion vascular marketing executive who has lately become sued by the company for seeking to steal workers after being left-wing.
“The delight of the worst thing I’ve had in my career,” he said.
Macdonald said he visited him at his home and asked questions about Modern Vascular through special agents from the FBI and the U. S. Department of Health and Human Services’ Office of Inspector General. U. S.
One of the lawsuits filed by the Justice Department alleged that Modern Vascular demanded unnecessary procedures for four patients referred through medical investors. The lawsuit claims Gampel boasted to investors that Modern Vascular was so successful that it was able to buy a Ferrari.
Two of the lawsuits filed through the Justice Department allege violations of the “Stark Act,” which prohibits doctors from sending others to a state-funded clinic in which they have an interest, with some exceptions.
In response to recent questions from a reporter on behalf of Modern Vascular, the public relations representative wrote, “These laws and regulations apply to our business. “
Speaking to medical investors at least a year ago, Modern Vascular said it would replace its business design to “reduce some legal physical care risks” and “comply with Stark, allowing us to capture the revenue streams related to designated fitness that is ultimately unavailable due to Stark Act requirements. “according to a Q&A document shared with The Republic.
Modern Vascular was reorganized so that medical investors would do business with a single national control company, rather than receiving dividends from the local clinic they sent patients to.
“This is a solution for the Stark Act,” said Dr. Marty Makary, a public fitness researcher and professor at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine. “If you don’t violate the letter of the Stark Act, you violate the spirit of the hard law. “
The Arizona Department of Health Services won a complaint that Modern Vascular was paying referring doctors more than two years ago, according to a state firm document. The document shows that regulators have decided they “have no jurisdiction over billing fraud procedures. “and that they merit referring the matter to the state prosecutor’s office and the medical commission. These units did not respond to a request for additional information.
Brower lost confidence after Modern Vascular failed to pay bills to investors, he explained. He shared emails in which he asked Modern Vascular control over unpaid bills, and a fellow podiatrist said the company hadn’t paid dividends in months. In the emails, the company said it was returning to quarterly rather than monthly invoices because it was making adjustments to its accounting policies.
After not receiving payment for a few months, Brower withdrew his money.
Now it refers to another part.
Looking back, Brower found that Modern Vascular operated on its patients at a much higher rate than the new organization to which it referred them.
“It was very apparent to me after I left,” he said.
Dr. Patrick Duffy’s workplace scarce. During his ninth week on assignment at Modern Vascular’s location in Surprise, his gray library was nearly empty and his gray walls were bare.
Gray carpet. Gray desk. Gray uniforms.
Neon sticky notes.
Duffy wrote down the names and numbers of doctors he sought out to court as possible sources of references. He said he planned to write letters to them.
“When you move to doctors and you’re looking to gain their trust, it doesn’t matter, you just need to say, ‘I can be a resource for you,'” Duffy said in an interview in June. “Because that’s what treating physicians need. “
Duffy was admitted to Modern Vascular from a Houston hospital and has a blank record with the Arizona Medical Board. He declined to say how much he pays now, but said he cut his base salary by 20% to enroll in Modern Vascular. They described having greater autonomy and a better work-life balance.
He allowed a journalist to observe his profession.
The cool operating room. The canopy of Smashmouth’s “I’m a Believer” ended the hum of machines.
Just for fun, they gave celebrity names to their craft team. Tim McGraw, the Rotablator, can simply knock down the blocks.
A patient lie under blue sheets, clinging to an IV. A little blood dripping on the ground. That’s normal, Duffy says.
All wore lead aprons and throat coverings, as the procedure involves using X-rays so the doctor can see a pulsed gray symbol of the patient’s right femoral artery, the giant one running down the leg, while feeding a cord. .
Duffy said the previous week he worked 60 to 65 hours and performed 11 surgeries. He denied tension for control to increase the numbers.
But he said he gets a bonus for the number of procedures he performs. It’s not an unusual practice, he said, but it can inspire a doctor to perform many procedures.
“I think if he’s not the right kind of person,” Duffy said, “he could. “
Lawsuits filed on behalf of 11 vascular patients claim they were abused.
Nina Robertson, 88, sought treatment at a trendy vascular clinic in Albuquerque.
They ruptured one of Robertson’s arteries and took her to the hospital with a blood clot in her abdomen the size of a basketball, she claimed in an ongoing lawsuit that Modern Vascular challenged in court.
“I was lucky, I got out of there alive, barely,” he said. Maybe some didn’t. “
She’s right.
In addition to the amputations, at least two other people died as a result of Modern Vascular’ procedures, according to the lawsuit’s allegations. surgery I didn’t need.
“Modern Vascular, LLC has an ongoing policy or practice to schedule patients for unnecessary angiograms and/or interventional procedures on patients’ lower extremities, regardless of medical necessity, for maximum monetary advantage and without regard to the safety and well-being of patients. “patients like Ms. Hendrix,” the lawsuit says. Modern Vascular has denied wrongdoing in court and the trial is ongoing.
Kae Barnes sued Brannan and the fashionable vascular doctor, claiming they had not tried conservative remedies before operating on him, claiming they had destroyed blood vessels, resulting in the amputation of his left leg.
“At the end of the procedure, when Brannan’s (Barnes) final judgment was over, she felt sharp, widespread pain in her ankle,” her trial said. There was a cord left. The cord ran from Barnes’ most sensitive leg to his ankle. Definishant Brannan got rid of the cord, closed it, and without delay left the room without saying a word.
Modern Vascular challenged Barnes’ claims in court.
Beyond the cases described in the lawsuits, police and EMS records show more patients with vascular problems. Doctors responding to the Tucson Vascular Clinic discovered a patient’s begging on an examination table after a procedure.
The doctor at the scene told doctors that the patient “bleeds inside. “The patient lost 3 liters of blood, about a part of the blood of an average adult.
Dr. Jack Hannalah, mentioned in the emergency reaction report, did not respond to calls and emails of a comment from a reporter.
A staff member grabbed the incision in the patient’s upper right thigh. She was numb and cold. Doctors accused her and took her to the hospital, with Hannalah pierced by the side.
She was left with no answer. The record comes with your call or says if you survived.
A guy dressed in papers approached Brannan’s Scottsdale home. No answer at the door, shutters closed, silence. But the garage door open, the light on, a van parked inside with the door open.
Brannan texted his wife, court records show, “I know this is a strange question, are you providing me with any services?”
It’s a divorce, which adds to Brannan’s complicated year in 2017. He eventually earned at least $196,000. But he moved 8 times that year and was evicted from a space for non-payment of rent, his ex-wife said. He later denied this claim in divorce arbitration.
As the turmoil in Brannan’s private life increased, he discovered tactics to increase his income.
He worked part-time with Modern Vascular from approximately July 2017 at the company’s Mesa location. Soon after, the Arizona Medical Board hit him with a warning letter for piercing a patient’s artery and “improper documentation. “
Their divorce has become controversial, with allegations of abuse and drug use. Mesa police investigated Brannan after his wife discovered nude photos of their children on a phone. Police decided they did not constitute child pornography, but discovered “numerous photographs and videos” of adult pornography, according to a police report.
Despite non-public problems, its source of income has increased, surpassing $450,000 in 2018. His wife claimed that his source of income was even greater in their divorce.
Modern Vascular has spread across the country, for concentrations of other seniors who might be more prone to the disease they are treating. Four places that sound like Phoenix. One in Tucson. . Louis, Indianapolis, Memphis and Mississippi.
Along the way, the company focused on numbers. An email shared with The Republic, its founder and former CEO, urged doctors to know how many procedures they had scheduled in a week.
“Are there 7 procedures this week?” Gampel wrote: “We showed 17 at the beginning of the week. “
Another Modern Vascular executive sent an email to the company’s doctors explaining how to use billing codes to generate revenue.
“This increases the refund by at least around 2,000 depending on the case,” the email reads.
Management pressured staff to carry out compliance measures, wondering if a clinic had complied with a target number of procedures in a week, according to a clinical director education consultant provided through a former employee. The document shows that one clinic emphasized carrying out procedures in part from the other people who came here for a consultation.
It is difficult to say how much fruit it has yielded. Modern Vascular is a private company and records of its source of income are difficult to obtain. When a Modern Vascular executive greeted a Republic reporter at a Glendale workplace this summer, it was empty. The executive said his team is running elsewhere.
When the Mississippi clinic opened in 2019, the company came up with financial estimates for that location, which ended up tying up with Brannan’s divorce. Modern Vascular estimated that the clinic would perform 254 outpatient visits and 364 procedures in the first year, charging $14,725 according to procedure, earning a profit margin of about 17%.
In 2020, Brannan was reimbursed more than $5. 5 million for 6,236 similar vascular procedures for his 286 patients, according to Medicare data. Ranked based on turnover, Brannan joins another popular vascular doctor in the top 10, with two more in the group. most sensible 50.
Analyzed in a way, Medicare data shows that Brannan and three other popular vascular doctors rank in the top 12 smartest based on how much they bill according to the patient.
“This is an outlier,” Dr. David Armstrong, a podiatrist and professor of surgery at the University of Southern California, said of the high-ranking organization of fashionable vascular doctors.
When asked about his senior rank, Brannan said he tends to perform procedures on one patient at a time, while other doctors would possibly bring patients back at another time. One of the lawsuits filed through the Justice Department claims Modern Vascular attempted to “maximize the amount of consistent benefit to the patient. “
A spokesman for the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services declined to comment on The Republic’s investigation, but showed it was not possible to pass judgment on the quality of their jobs or whether it was medically necessary.
Brannan has also become one of the top medical products from a representative of Boston Scientific, a medical device company that generated nearly $12 billion in revenue in 2021.
A sure symbiosis between device brands and surgeons is part of American fitness care. Boston Scientific makes wires, balloons and stents that doctors like Brannan use to open arteries. The progression of smaller devices through corporations like Boston Scientific in consultation with doctors like Brannan enables procedures that Modern Vascular touts as revolutionary.
A Boston Scientific representative in Arizona said in a 2020 filing as a component of Brannan’s divorce that Modern Vascular was granted a 13% reduction for the product it uses. He said his company expects Modern Vascular to use Boston Scientific products 80 percent of the time. He estimated the refund would be $250,000 in line with the 2019 quarter.
Rep. Josh Thomas said he didn’t know how much, if any, of that money went to Brannan.
Brannan has become very close to Thomas. His sons played on the same football team. They went to the birthday parties of others’ children.
Brannan has been arrested in the past on a low-level arrest warrant for failing to appear in court to respond to a subpoena to drive with a suspended license and no evidence of insurance. He was taken out with two pairs of handcuffs, according to the police report. The fountain connects two sets to tie the wrists of tall people.
Thomas rescued him, according to a police report.
Thomas also named the Boston Scientific director who “turned a blind eye” to internal memos that said trendy vascular doctors were performing unnecessary invasive procedures with Boston Scientific equipment, according to a complaint in one of the lawsuits filed with the Justice Department in September.
The lawsuit says sales representatives for the medical device giant saw trendy vascular doctors perform dyeing tests that showed patients’ arteries were clean, but trendy vascular doctors were still scheduling surgeries. When sales reps complained to Thomas and senior executives, they were ignored, according to the lawsuit, because Boston Scientific executives didn’t need to disrupt the company’s lucrative sales.
“We strongly disagree with the baseless allegations defined in this filing, as we have conducted an investigation when considerations have been raised and no misplaced conduct has occurred through Boston Scientific or its employees,” corporate spokesman Blake Rouhani said in an email. The company declined to give the main points of what the investigation revealed. A company representative said Thomas was still contracted through Boston Scientific. His attorney declined to answer questions, but said in an email: “Mr. Thomas’ conduct with respect to Dr. Thomas Brannan and Modern Vascular was professional and appropriate.
The Ministry of Justice refused to prosecute Brannnan directly in this trial. But it was reviewed by the Arizona Medical Board, which, in a 2020 advisory letter, rebuked its “failure to offer adequate and established remedy opportunities to patients as their condition worsened despite acting multiple endovascular procedures. “
Brannan responded, “I, the Council, unfairly oppose sub-knee vascular procedures and published this letter in its bias. “
In August, Brannan sat in front of the Arizona Medical Board for two hours to answer for 8 possible violations. They suggested about the use of Ambien and prescribing medication to his wife without keeping a record.
He was asked about steroid use. He said he was prescribed testosterone and bought a “prohormone” called “trenabol” on eBay. I had read on online forums that I would lose fat and increase power and strength. He said he took on this supplement. it was metabolized into a substance that caused him to fail a steroid test.
He said in an interview that he stopped taking Trenabol but continued to take other supplements, as long as they were not illegal.
“There are things they say, you know, it’s going to have a similar effect to testosterone. And, you know, some other people are stupid enough for that,” Brannan said. stupid enough to do this and cross your fingers, I hope it’s true. “
The advice is about his patient who died in 2017.
Claude DesChamps, an internal representative for the Arizona Medical Board, weighed in before council members voted.
“In Dr. Brannan’s eagerness to effectively repair arterial flow, he ignored the symptoms of deterioration that led him to begin earlier the transfer of care to a hospital,” DesChamps said at the hearing. He said he died of a hemorrhage.
Like Brannan before, he stood firm calmly, flanked by a lawyer and tried to do it himself.
“I think I’ve moved forward on things over time,” he told the board. “And I just have to take on the duty of documentation and fear about my use of Ambien and that’s resolved. “
The council voted to censure him, demanding a year of probation and drug treatment. The order would be final if approved at a board meeting in October. You are one step away from wasting your license.
He is loose to continue practicing.
The growth of trendy vascular clinics across the country continued. The company opened a clinic in Memphis in February. He recently opened another one in Louisville.
Former Modern Vascular workers and other doctors in the network have expressed concern about retaliation for reporting the clinic. In addition to the lawsuit against a former Modern Vascular marketing executive filed through the chain’s controlling company, Modern Vascular sued a clinic with one name sued Searchlight New Mexico, which wrote about Modern Vascular’s lawsuits.
An internal email shared with The Republic shows that medical director Dr. Steve Berkowitz attempted to limit pain in the wake of the New Mexico story, which said Modern Vascular “drives remedies and puts profits before patients. “
“We have super opportunities here for story redirection, positive PR, and credibility on the street!” wrote Berkowitz, recommending “redirecting the narrative to. . . reduce unnecessary amputations. “
When Berkowitz heard that a Republic reporter was contacting former employees, he contacted and welcomed the reporter and photographer for a field trip to the Glendale clinic.
In an icy operating room, he presented a fierce defense of the company.
It showed that Modern Vascular is under “investigation” through the Justice Department. It doesn’t talk about the company’s investors. He said the company had a target number of procedures for each clinic: the Glendale clinic 15 per week. And yes, this number influences a doctor’s decision whether or not to perform surgery.
“To say it’s not true, because we have to have a business,” he said.
He summed it up in practical terms.
“If you run a pizzeria and don’t sell enough pizza, you’re not going to stay in business,” Berkowitz said.
On a recent weekday, Brannan said he had to deal with six instances and had just worked a few 14-hour days. He says long days are never a problem. In a statement, he said he can perform 1,000 procedures a year.
“I don’t know if he’s sleeping,” Berkowitz said. I mean, that’s what he likes. It does not reject a case.
As a second-hand salesman, Mike Bonebrake understands the thirst for numbers.
But that’s no consolation.
For 30 years, Bonebrake made a lot of money and supported his wife, daughter and granddaughter. He said he was a sponsored semi-professional fisherman, learned to fly an airplane and, at 6 feet, 2 inches, enjoyed betting on basketball.
Now, Bonebrake, 60, said he couldn’t succeed in the smartest thing in his fridge.
Bonebrake had an ingrown toenail that did not heal. He went to a number one care physician’s office, where a medical assistant may not feel a strong pulse in his foot and sought him out for a check.
His records at Bonebrake imply that he had factors, a stroke and a central seizure in the past, and smoked.
Dr. Marc Eckhauser worked on his left leg. The public relations company representing Modern Vascular declined to comment on his behalf.
Bonebrake said his foot nearly doubled its previous size. It hurts. He returned to Modern Vascular and was told he looked better.
At a follow-up appointment a week later, his foot was swollen and sore, leaving him unable to walk. The fashionable vascular doctor admitted that he would like to have him amputated. Siegrist, the surgeon who amputated Bonebrake, told The Republic Bonebrake that he did not want the procedure to be performed through Modern Vascular, a claim echoed in lawsuits filed on behalf of other patients.
Bonebrake spent an entire day figuring out how to get on a walker and get to the bathroom, he said. What may be just nine stages looks like a 9-mile race.
“You know, just knowing what they’re doing bothers me,” he said. “And it drives me crazy, you know, it drives me crazy. It makes me need to fight those people. “
As he sat on the edge of his bed where he spends most of his days, his wife walked in with a bill in her hand.
Modern Vascular wanted $372. 94.
Stories like this are imaginable thanks to our subscribers like you. Your help will allow us to continue producing quality journalism.
Stay informed by subscribing to one of our newsletters.