To review this article, My Account, then View Saved Stories
To review this article, My Profile and then View Saved Stories
By Tad amigo
Korean fried fish near Los Angeles wasn’t exactly a crime scene. But on a rainy fall afternoon, two of Mexico’s most no-nonsense wildlife traffickers were sitting in the back, eating lunch and talking business. One of their most successful lines of business is smuggling floating bladders from an endangered fish called totoaba. Scabies-colored bladders are notoriously disgusting, and the effort to collect them in the Sea of Cortez has pushed the vaquita to the point of extinction. Your skin glows! Or popular wisdom does. They have become expensive enough in China, up to fifty thousand dollars consistent with one kilogram, to be gifted or bribed or simply loved as collector’s items, such as Fabergé eggs.
The traffickers, Harry and Tommy, were Chinese. Harry, tall and plump, stood on his chopsticks, while Tommy paced and talked on the phone. The two men believed their host, Billy, a friend of several years, was a Hong Kong businessman looking to use their smuggling route. In fact, Billy, who was recording their verbal exchange on his iPhone, was an agent of an NGO called Earth League International. (I used a pseudonym for anyone known through a single name. )ELI intends to prevent the global industry of rhino horn, elephant ivory, shark fins, lizards, ploughed turtles, Queen Alexandra flies and more than seven thousand other species. Their goal is not to catch poachers to penetrate transnational smuggling networks that, according to some estimates, move more than a hundred billion dollars a year.
At a table across the room, Andrea Crosta, the founder of ELI, watches the action with Mark Davis, her director of intelligence. They watched Billy pass out to smoke, which can capture a wonderful conversation,” Crosta said. He looked and laughed: Harry and Tommy were quietly passing with bulpassgi. “I have almost no emotions towards those people,” he said. They’re in the death business, and I don’t like them because of that, but it would be counterproductive to hate them. “
Crosta, a fifty-four-year-old Italian with light blue eyes and a melancholy look, buys a one-bedroom apartment in Marina del Rey with his rescue dog, Argos. Like many animal lovers, he is disappointed by humans. “one of my favorite people,” Jane Goodall told me. He is passionate, brave, what he is doing is very harmful, he loves dogs and will never give up. “he goes all day without eating, and then, at nightfall, digs himself up looking at the mackerel soil in the bucket of Argos.
ELI’s annual budget is only $350,000, yet its operations have led to the arrest of an alleged jaguar tusk network in Bolivia; helped the Mexican government prosecute the Cartel del Mar, a Baja California network that trafficked sea cucumbers and totoaba; and has triggered at least seven ongoing investigations through the Fish and Wildlife Service, the Department of Homeland Security and the F. B. I. These agencies now treat ELI as trusted colleagues. Chris Egner, the Homeland Security officer who works hard with the Cresta team, told me, “Our partnership with ELI is invaluable. Their relationship with those specific criminal networks is all we can’t do.
After lunch, Crosta and Davis went to a nearby boba shop and waited outside to question Billy. A handyman, Billy speaks Cantonese, Mandarin, several Chinese dialects, English and some Spanish and French, and has worked undercover on five continents. He has the gift of appearing rich, venal and dense: the best customer. He bounced off the sidewalk and began his report: “It’s going well!At first they were a little cautious. They asked, “Where is the boss?”Billy’s The Boss had been played through Larry, another undercover agent, but Larry was traveling that week. “I said, ‘Oh, they gave him COVID. ‘”
“Good!” Mark Davis said, admiring the improvisation and providing a momentary take, “Oh, he’s dead. “Davis retired from the F. B. I. in 2016, after thirty years as the agency’s top undercover agent. He played some two hundred roles and laughed at the drug cartels led by Pablo Escobar and El Chapo. , Davis has a surfer drifter vibe that’s as captivating as it is deceptive. He works for ELI without pay.
Once Harry and Tommy relaxed, Billy said, they described a variety of schemes implemented through their associates, adding to load sea cucumbers to San Diego and making counterfeit Gucci bags. They also explained how they smuggled Chinese nationals into the United States, through Macau and Ecuador. “They use fake Japanese green cards that bring other people to Mexico City and then bribe customs to bring them on local flights to Tijuana,” Billy said. “Then the sign takes them across the border via a mountain road. “Tommy admitted that uncertainties worried: “Sometimes the cartel would take your money and crazy things would happen. But there were usually no rapes. “
Crosta knew that those main points would be of interest to national security, an important attention for ELI. Generally speaking, law enforcement cares less about animals and more about “convergence,” the other crimes committed by wildlife traffickers. Golden Triangle traffickers who smuggle pangolins and bears into China also traffic opium and methamphetamines; the organization that brings monkeys to Europe from northern Morocco also transports hashish, counterfeits and other people. Crosta aims to leverage the agencies’ program for himself. “You wouldn’t scare other people if you arrested them for wildlife trafficking,” he said. in the restaurant. ” They should be charged with human trafficking and money laundering and locked up for twenty years. “
Davis added, “I don’t care if those bastards start promoting cocaine, we just need to put them out of business on Mother Earth. “
The challenge for ELI is that while most people treat nature as an inexhaustible resource, traffickers know better. Billy reported that Harry said, “Seafood, I won’t do it now because it’s not sustainable. “Davis laughed and Crosta said, “Of course, of course,” his very old reaction to the ecological destruction caused by human greed. Everyone says there are fewer and fewer rhino horns and shark fins, so we have to catch as much as we can before it’s over. “
Reports of wildlife trafficking have a “strange news” look: the passenger stopped at Amsterdam airport with hummingbirds in his underwear; travelers from Guyana arriving in J. F. K. carrying dozens of curlers, each of which contains a brown-bellied sporophyll. (Finches are meant to participate in singing contests on the Queens Guyanese network, where a melodious to know can sell for more than ten thousand dollars. )
The strangeness of those stories obscures a pernicious effect of globalization: a blurring of the global wildlife map. South American butterflies arrive in the United States after being transported through Thailand; Mexican cartels sell bavia tigers. In this sector, animals are transported overnight, dead or alive, to where they have the maximum value. Nils Gilman, a globalization expert at the Berggruen Institute, told me, “When the difference in value is based on differences in ethical opinion, the probability of sustainable profit margins is very high. “Sometimes rhino horn was worth more than gold. For example, South African rhinos are killed with Czech-made rifles sold through Portuguese arms dealers to poachers in Mozambique, who send the horns by mail. to Qatar or Vietnam, or wrap them with elephant ivory in Maputo, Mombasa, Lagos or Luanda and send them to China via Malaysia or Hong Kong.
copied link
Social media is a difficult market enabler and accelerator. A 2020 study on Facebook found four hundred and seventy-three pages that shamelessly swapped and another two hundred and eighty-one teams that participated in the global bazaar. The key words were clear: “bone ox” for elephant ivory, “striped shirt” for tiger skin. Gretchen Peters, director of the Alliance to Counter Online Crime, which conducted the study, told me: “Everything from tarantulas to cheetahs to elephants collapses once it starts evolving.
Up to one million species of plants and animals are expected to disappear by 2050. 93% of the world’s fish stocks are fully or overexploited. On Earth, humans now make up 36% of the vertebrate population and livestock 50% nine %; All other land animals account for only five percent. Erasure begins every time a path is dug in a virgin forest. Timber, mining and palm oil plantations or farm animal ranches followed temporarily, as did poaching and trafficking. A road in the Congo, wildlife populations in the surrounding forest were reduced by more than twenty-five percent in just 3 weeks.
The main weapon opposing wildlife trafficking is the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora. CITES, proposed in 1973, has been signed in almost every country in the world and governs how more than 40,000 species move. the world. But the deal, designed to speed up the industry rather than suppress it, is unworkable in many tactics. Elephant trophies with tusks can be exchanged, but elephant ivory cannot; in the CITES database, customs officials will have to identify a species through its Latin name before they can intervene. More importantly, CITES has no enforcement mechanism and does not specify what to do with confiscated animals, which are slaughtered. John Scanlon, who was the Secretary-General of CITES from 2010 to 2018 told me: “It is quite evident that there is no way to combat transnational organised crime by employing a fifty-year industrial agreement.
Trafficking has global consequences. When species are removed from an environment, carbon sequestration and pollination decline, fires and floods are less controlled, and animal-borne diseases such as bird flu and HIV. stand up and spread. However, there is no global will to supplant CITES. “Because the word ‘wildlife’ is in wildlife crime, governments don’t take it seriously,” said Mary Rice, chief executive of the UK’s Environmental Investigation Agency, an influential conservation group. “They think of cute little animals. They don’t see it through the prism of a criminal act that amounts to conspiracy, bribery, corruption and murder. The world spends a hundred billion dollars a year to prevent drug trafficking, and much less than a billion to prevent wildlife trafficking. For the most part, the equipment used to pursue drug traffickers – wiretaps, undercover informants – are unknown in the fight against wildlife crime. A senior UN environmental crime official told me that in one Nordic country “environmental officials were known as the Snake Squad: two late-career civil servants relegated to an administrative office. “
The United States is known as the world’s animal policeman. The Lacey Act, along with other federal laws, states that if the component of an illegal wildlife transaction touches U. S. territory. In the US, even if the payment is only made through a server in the US. However, while Homeland Security gets nine hundred and fifty billion dollars in annual funding, its Wildlife and Environmental Crime Unit, which will be introduced this year, will get only $7. 5 million. The Office of Fish and Wildlife Law Enforcement has a budget of ninety-four million dollars, but even that is not enough to impede global trade. When I spent a day with his officials at the J. F. K. , Paul Chapelle, the New York District tax agent, told me, “We are surely beyond our capabilities. There were 3 inspectors at the airport, who had to check 400 tons of mail, 4000 tons of shipping and more than 100000 passengers.
Inspectors are tasked with countering a critical need. We locate wild animals that are more beautiful, more exotic, healthier, tastier and more effective than pets. All over the world, they are used as medicines, as subjects of laboratory experiments, as accessories for selfies, as pets, as food, for their skins and furs, for breeding purposes and for hunting. Even childish wonder is related to this incomplete cleaning; the owl industry skyrocketed after “Harry Potter. “What unites those uses is a preference for the atavism of animals, their astonishing strangeness. We assign to them all the savage qualities that we have lost and aspire to destroy.
The infinity pool shone in the October twilight over the Los Angeles Basin. Jim Demetriades, businessman and environmentalist, organizes a fundraiser for Earth League International at his Tuscan-style mansion in Beverly Hills, a stall called Villa Theos, Greco-Roman for “God’s Country House. “Eighty superbly dressed people filled the lawn, adding director Oliver Stone and actress Rebecca De Mornay. Crosta found himself hoping to accumulate his entire budget by five hundred thousand dollars that night.
There were pitfalls to avoid. Demetriades’ circle of relatives and his team were republicans and hunters, so Crosta had gone out of his way to make sure that his leader’s snacks did not repel vegans. Demetriades then argued in his opening remarks that his daughter was on the ELI board of directors, although she had not gone beyond the discussion stage. Crosta remained silent: maybe we deserve to appoint her to the board, so she and Jim will do it to us.
He told me, “Our biggest covert challenge is fundraising. I hate it, I suck at it. Crosta had attended galas that raised millions with emotional appeals, but found this technique unpleasant. He said: “I once brought a big donor and she said, ‘Don’t you have anything better I can do with my child, like adopting an orphaned baby elephant?’In Los Angeles, they are obsessed with adopting three, five, ten orphaned baby elephants. I’m running to produce fewer orphaned baby elephants. “We didn’t get any money.
“Adopting” baby elephants is a key tactic of conservation NGOs: a way to attract investment for less charismatic wildlife. Rikkert Reijnen, advisor to the International Fund for Animal Welfare (IFAW), explained: “Elephants want space and you can protect them many animals in that space. The maximum vital animal in this formula is the termite. Termites recycle dead wood and leaves and aerate the soil; Without them, there would be no plants to feed the animals. Inive poster child”.
Crosta, wearing everything he could bear, had stamped a photo of a mother elephant and her bath on posters for the event. And he began his presentation by recalling his early days as a security representative who sometimes trained park rangers: “My story begins twelve years ago in Kenya, in the midst of the elephant poaching crisis, when we wasted up to fifty thousand elephants a year. horrific scenes from my life: a total organization of elephants who had been shot with AK-47s, just for ivory. There was only one survivor, a small elephant later named Zambezi, cut into the spine. He was probably looking to protect his mother. What I don’t forget are the faces of the rangers. He gestured, evoking helplessness. ” The next day, they really caught two of the others involved, and you can’t believe two poorer, more desperate and filthy ones, earning a few dollars for every kilo of ivory, where the traffickers made thousands. “
As Crosta reviewed photographs of a rhino horn smuggler in Vietnam, orphaned orangutans in Thailand, and illegal timber in Gabon, he explained how ELI works: “We assembled a team of former undercover F. B. I. operators. and the CIA to infiltrate the world’s top operatives. “groups of wildlife traffickers. Twelve undercover agents of other nationalities, and their task is to identify those other people and make friends with them. We never buy anything illegal, we’re not armed, we’re just too smart to be your friend. This review was somewhat misleading: although ELI has used agents from Taiwan, South Africa, and Colombia, it usually only uses two or three undercover agents at a time, and none of them are former members of the agency (a former C. I. A. agent. he said he would sign up for once, Crosta can do it. ) And ELI infrequently engages in acquisitions on behalf of law enforcement: In 2021, at the request of federal agents, Billy and Larry spent hours in a U-Haul parked outside a McDonald’s in San Diego, negotiating the purchase of totoaba bladders from a dealer.
Crosta’s lies and elisions were due in part to shyness: “I’m almost embarrassed to say how small we are,” and in part to the desire of his team. When buying U-Haul, the trafficker brought in a counter-surveillance team from a drug cartel. Crosta told me, “We’ve made a lot of paintings for this purchase, but we can’t take public credits because the poster is a danger to us. “
At Villa Theos, Rebecca De Mornay told Demetriades: “It’s exciting!It’s so vital that it’s a movie. He nodded excitedly: “This is NASA, this is the future!”But many in the crowd aren’t convinced by Crosta’s approach. Two visitors advised ELI team members that instead of sympathizing with poachers, they should move on to Africa and kill them.
Donors love direct action and like to feel that their donation solves the problem. For example, NGOs publish photos of rescued animals and fly over measurable results. Jane Goodall told me, “Facts, facts, facts; Other people don’t care. “On Crosta’s situation, he said: “I would show a video of cutting a scale from a live pangolin. Then I would jump into photographs of a big, large, complacent pivot eating pangolin meat and tiger bones, inciting other people to look at hate. “, because there is no end to the efforts other people will make to follow their beastly path. And then it would show a pangolin recovering in a sanctuary. You have to end on a positive note.
When the merit was over, Demetriades invited the Earth League team and a dozen other mentally retarded people to his underground bunker, which contained a wine cellar, bowling alley, nightclub, and shooting range. Shotguns glowed on the walls. Demetriades pulled Cuban cigars from a winery and served Château Smith Haut Lafitte 2005. For some, the evening became a bit hectic. When everyone came out, an hour or two later, the technician who had emphasized the A. V. He was limping. the driveway, he had just been bitten by one of Demetriades’ dogs. (Demetriades denies this. ) When revelers pointed their phone lights at the technician’s shin and exclaimed blood, someone showed up to shoot the dog. “It’s time to pass,” he muttered Crosta. Es time to pass now. “
According to Crosta’s calculation, ELI could provoke traffic in much of the world with a prize of ten million dollars. The event had raised $11,500 hope,” he said. Hope is just a commodity, promoting beautiful words and images to you. People who participate in those fundraisers need to have fun, forget, because they feel guilty for not having done enough for the Earth. Wealthy donors, he said, are “like the puppy that focuses on a flower, then a butterfly passes, and they stick to that. “
In November, a Cambodian named Masphal Kry was arrested at JFK for his role in allegedly trafficking two thousand six hundred and thirty-four long-tailed macaques to American pharmaceutical companies, to be used as control subjects. Kry was deputy director of his country’s Department of Wildlife and Biodiversity, addressing a CITES convention in Panama; His boss was also charged. Many of those charged with protecting their country’s resources end up exploiting them. Malaysia’s former Minister of Planning and Resource Management allowed the destruction of Sarawak’s rainforest. Burundi’s ivory stockpiles have been looted several times, stored in an army compound.
Because so many countries facilitate wildlife crime, NGOs have tried to fill the gap in law enforcement. For decades, they have supported military-style education of rangers in Africa, a technique known as “fortress conservation. “The Kenya Wildlife Service in 1989, instituted a policy of shooting poachers on the spot, which was temporarily extended to parks across the continent and beyond. On a reservation in India, the rule is simply “kill the undesirables. “
Poachers can also be blind. They killed elephants using strychnine-enriched oranges or pesticides, which had the added effect of killing vultures, whose circles might otherwise alert keepers of a dead elephant. NGOs are no longer comfortable with shoot-to-kill policies, with the investment of a paramilitary institution,” Brighton Kumchedwa, Malawi’s director of parks and wildlife, told me. The preservation of the fortresses also proved inevitably neocolonial: the creation of African parks led to the forced displacement of the Maasai and Wameru peoples, among many others.
From 2015 to 2017, Damien Mander, a former Australian commando, helped lead what he calls a “grassroots offensive opposed to the local population” to prevent poaching in South Africa’s Kruger National Park. “We had a hundred and sixty-five more people, helicopters, drones, dog attack teams,” he told me. “We were necessarily an occupying force. ” Realizing that the result, at most, would be a Pyrrhic victory, he introduced a program that deploys female rangers in 4 African countries. inside,” Mander said. You are on a continent that will have another two billion people by 2040; A prolonged confrontation with the local population is not the way forward. “Ultimately, the conservation of the castle is based on a landscape devoid of other people.
However, the biggest challenge with castle conservation is that it doesn’t work. “Each rhino has its own defense system,” said IFAW’s Rikkert Reijnen, exaggerating: the last two northern white rhinos live under 24-hour cover in Kenya. And they’re still being poached. “
As a teenager in Milan, Andrea Crosta used earplugs to sleep because his room was so noisy. It was the home of an African grey parrot; softshell and red-eared turtles; an aquarium filled with angelfish, grouse, guppies, baleen and a red-tailed shark; a python; and his cat, Goccia. “I have more happiness with animals than with my human interactions,” he told me. His parents divorced when he was seven. “I think that day destroyed my ability to accept having children as truth or necessity,” she said. “Not to mention, my mom then killed herself with gas in the car, which she left me twice. I still wonder: what if I had watched TV the day the divorce was announced, like my brother?– Nicola was eighteen months younger – “and that was the one they had announced?Because he has been married for twenty years and has 3 children.
While Crosta was at the University of Milan, studying zoology, he worked in a breeding center for endangered species. He had hoped to continue there after graduation, but the center couldn’t. So he served a stint as an army policeman, worked at crisis PR, and then set up an online sales company called Think Italy, which was briefly worth 8 million euros, until the dotcom crash in 2000. Always restless, he has become a security advisor. The work, which concerned collaboration with Italy’s anti-terror police unit and vendors from Israel’s elite cyber squad, familiarized him with a variety of threats.
In 2011, while in Kenya, advising a security team of former Somali Prime Minister Ali Mohamed Gedi, Crosta became acquainted with the organization of AK-47 shooting elephants. He knew that in other cases he would have committed the same crime: “Of course I would be a poacher, if killing an elephant earned me 4 years’ salary to feed my family. If I introduced other people here in Los Angeles to the 4-year salary, they would bring me their mother.
He and an Israeli colleague, Nir Kalron, began raising money to exercise the rangers. But Crosta has become increasingly aware that poaching was inseparable from the monetary and political networks that stretched across the globe. The U. S. intelligence network The U. S. had already begun to perceive wildlife trafficking as either a cause and effect of instability. Rod Schoonover, a State Department analyst at the time, told me, “Biodiversity loss has begun to become a national security issue. This has security consequences: water stress, food stress, civil unrest, deep corruption.
copied link
Working for Gedi, Crosta and Kalron had heard that Al-Shabaab, the terrorist organization that controlled much of Somalia, was exporting ivory to China. They investigated, with some clumsiness: their clandestine videos showed a glass of orange juice or the curtain of a hotel room. and spoke to a dozen sources. In 2013, they finished a study that found Al-Shabaab trafficked up to 3 tons of ivory per month.
Crosta and O. N. G. called the Elephant Action League and posted a summary of the study on their website, but no one picked it up. Al-Shabaab then attacked the Westgate Mall in Nairobi, killing seventy-one. attack in Kenya,” and the Times and other newspapers discussed E. A. L’s findings.
Foreign protest over the attack contributed to China’s 2017 resolution to ban ivory altogether. However, Crosta and Kalron’s study angered some conservation NGOs, who thought they had decorated their data. Rosaleen Duffy, a political environmentalist, argued in an article written with colleagues that the test was “poorly tested” and “based on false assumptions. ” She also claimed that she promotes the US global agenda.
Crosta said, “There was a camp that saw terrorists everywhere, and a camp that didn’t see them anywhere, and we were in the middle with our little studio. “He then published a full report detailing his findings: “The mistake we made in the original to not contextualize ivory trafficking as just one component of how Al-Shabaab was funded. They have also been implicated in kidnappings, piracy and charcoal. He added: “They gave me a ton for our original study to China, so I’m happy, because it helped the elephants.
Once Crosta understood the implications of Al-Shabaab’s investment, he had to find a way to hint at the trafficking networks. He started WildLeaks, a site where other people can simply report traffic anonymously, and eventually reformed the Elephant Action League into Earth League International. In 2017, he learned that informants in South Africa had a wealth of data. He flew to Johannesburg and met 3 men at a deserted ranch near the Botswana border. Two worked security; the third was a former police officer. South Africa’s wildlife was an infamous global buffet: For years, Vietnamese and Laotian networks transported Thai prostitutes and registered them as “rhino hunters” for a CITES-sanctioned “trophy” cull. (Czech skirmishers were imported to do the actual killing. ) Still, Crosta was stunned by what he was shown. “They had incredible data on the rhino horn trade,” he said. “There were links to the Chinese embassy, links to the North Korean embassy, links to terrorist teams in Zambia and Mozambique, many other people in the government on the payroll, plus a senior South African leader and his son. We were walking in his crime map, it was so big.
The informants had main points of two dozen networks, and an unsentimental plan to burden them: “They were looking for a hundred thousand dollars according to the network to pass and capture the leaders, or kill them if necessary, and millions more to blow up a helicopter. “to Mozambique to take down a major trafficker. Crosta had neither the budget nor the murderous inclination to fall. But, he said, “it’s a pivotal moment. ” I learned that there were 300 environmental organizations in South Africa alone that were engaged in advocacy, outreach, social media and local communities; However, the world needed a genuine company to combat those guys. Because we were like scouts standing up to Escobar.
When Tom Toth, a fish and wildlife inspector, showed me J. F. K. ‘s outbound mail facility, he passed containers of packages bound for South America and Europe and planted himself near one marked “China. “Check out to check each and every package that comes out,” he said. Paul Chapelle, the lead agent, chimed in, adding, diplomatically, “We’re all over Asia, really. “
Blaming a country or region for wildlife trafficking is a complicated issue. “Everyone is sensitive, because the challenge is presented as ‘the West in opposition to China,'” Rikkert Reijnen said. It temporarily leads to Chinese interests. ” Many of Crosta’s tactical, strategic, and ontological considerations relate to Chinese traffickers and buyers. “They eat the living planet,” he told me. They have this pantagruelic appetite for everything. “
Through the Belt and Road Initiative, China has forged ties with one hundred and forty-nine countries, spending more than a trillion dollars to expand roads, bridges and ports and for poorer countries to open up their herbal resources. The effect is an open industrial flow, whether licit or illicit. A Chinese trafficker in Peru told an ELI agent that embassy officials would evaluate China’s request: “Who or what company wants seafood?Who wants a treasure or a very rare specialty? »
China is by far the smartest destination for illegal wildlife: between 2009 and 2021, there were at least 750 airport seizures of goods destined for China; the next largest offender, Vietnam, had one hundred and thirty-five and the United States ninety-four. One of the main driving forces is classical Chinese medicine. China expands the T. C. M. throughout the world, especially in Africa, planning, according to its State Council, to turn it into a four hundred and twenty billion dollar industry. Although the maximum T. C. M. ingredients are botanical, the pharmacopoeia includes products of seventy animal species. Rhino horn, now banned, has long been considered to cure impotence, and pangolin scales are used to cure rheumatism and lactation. The healing mechanism is obscure, as rhino horn and pangolin scales are composed of keratin, the tissue of our nails. However, one hundred thousand pangolins are killed a year for their meat and scales; The 4 Asian species have been hunted almost to extinction, and the 4 African species are next.
Demand is created through ever-changing narratives. For decades, rhino horn was basically destined for Yemen, to make dagger handles. In 2007, only 13 rhinos were poached in South Africa, home to most of the world’s population. Vietnam that a politician had been cured of cancer by drinking horn. (Some conservationists created this story through the politician himself, who later started the horn trade. )Over the next seven years, the number of rhinos poached in South Africa skyrocketed to ninety. -two percent. More recently, club enthusiasts in Southeast Asia have snorted rhino horn powder as if it were cocaine.
The government has curtailed the sale of illegal money on social media, and a court recently convicted seventeen other people from the criminal ring organized by Chen’s relatives of trafficking more than twenty tons of ivory. Both ringleaders were sentenced to life imprisonment and confiscation of all their property. non-public property. But the repression is punctual. “China has processed a lot of wildlife cases, far more than any other Asian country,” Scott Roberton, executive director of anti-trafficking at the Wildlife Conservation Society, told me. “And it’s still not enough. “
The fighting between the country’s factions leads to ambivalent policies. In 2016, China modernized its coverage law, reversing language stating that animals exist for human use and benefit, however, similar language was recently reinstated in the law. The T. C. M. Ingredients Registry has dropped pangolin scales as an independent remedy, yet still approves them as an element in many patented medicines. After COVID-19 emerged, the government temporarily banned the sale of wild animals in rainy markets, however, other officials promoted bear bile as a cure for the virus.
NGOs with offices in China threaten to be expelled if they confront the government over such contradictions. The director of one of those offices told me, “If we say, ‘We want to decrease the demand for these products among the Chinese people. ‘”They will say, ‘Why are you communicating about the call?This suggests that China’s economic progress is related to illegal behavior!Then we learned to say, ‘How can we raise awareness about this issue?’The Chinese personality is that we wait to hear smart things, and only then can we be inspired to do better.
When Crosta started working with Mark Davis in 2016, he assessed what other NGOs were doing. The conservation of the fortresses proved insufficient, but no one had another comprehensive approach. Several organizations were working on “capacity building” in resource-rich countries. The Basel Institute of Governance is working with state agencies in places like Peru, Uganda and Malawi to help them with their protocols. Juhani Grossmann, who heads Basel’s green anti-corruption program, told me: “If the threat of the government official factoring in a fake permit increases, the amount of the bribe increases and the profit margin decreases. That’s what I hope anyway. “
Investigating traffickers was another matter. Their task is systematically negligent, as they do not take into account the gravity of their crimes. A major Vietnamese ivory and rhino horn trafficker used the same phone number for years; as well as one of Africa’s largest ivory traffickers. However, his persecutors were equally negligent. Among researchers, a few weeks in the box in Zambia can make you an expert. A former law enforcement official who has worked with environmental NGOs told me, “I’ve noticed anti-wildlife trafficking operations where other people get ‘in the background. ‘up’ education watching ‘C. S. I. ‘ and ‘Narcos’. “
Environmental activists were killed in at least sixty-four countries between 2015 and 2019. Even qualified agents are at serious risk. Wayne Lotter, who helped manage the PAMS Foundation, an NGO, who was instrumental in the imprisonment of Tanzania’s so-called ivory queen. , was ambushed in a taxi in 2017 by killers who fled with her laptop. Eleven other people were sentenced to death for the murder, but it is unclear that the ringleaders were among them. Lotter co-founder Krissie Clark, who was in the taxi with him, told me, “We’re still trying to figure out which button we accidentally pressed. “
Crosta, looking to design a more effective organization, was inspired by Ofir Drori of an African NGO called AIGLE. Drori, who looks like a pirate, has arrested more than 3,000 smugglers, adding Guinea’s former senior CITES official. (The official was convicted but received a presidential pardon. ) He explained that once he had evidence against a trafficker, I met with the right minister: force. And I won’t tell you or them who the trafficker is until we’re home. We work more from a position of strength than of relationship. However, Crosta feared that many of Drori’s targets were henchmen: “Ofir harshly portrayed the worst years of elephant poaching, arresting tons of people, and the challenge was getting worse and worse.
Crosta planned to identify his superiors and collect data on them until his records forced a prosecution. But engaging with other nonprofits was difficult; concepts considered by most as a valuable resource. Rob Parry-Jones, who leads the wildlife crime initiative at W. W. F. International told me: “NGOs do not need percentages of data on traffic, for security reasons, but also because they lose their competitiveness. “advantage, their ability to say to a donor, ‘We’re the only ones who perceive this. ‘”
While Crosta investigated, his purpose was to be patient, pro, and invisible. A host country doesn’t even know ELI is there. Billy doesn’t stay at the hotel where he accomplishes his purposes (so they can’t bribe the receptionist to read about his passport), and the team communicates with him via encrypted apps. Computers are remote, and Crosta helps you keep your schedule on a tamper-proof medium: a paper calendar in the workplace.
Many of Billy’s interactions in a new country begin with “cold snaps,” probably accidental crashes. After befriending a target, “if we have chemistry, I say, ‘Oh, do you have sea cucumber?'” he told me. It is helping him to sympathize with the traffickers, to some extent. “Some have a charming character: loyal, generous, brave, a clever sense of humor,” he said. “They came here to Africa with their parents, let’s say, and they learned Swahili and English and all the main points of the shipping industry, even though they didn’t finish university. Commendable! But they were predestined for this terrible task through their parents, who also did it.
Billy’s flexible resume allows him to explore almost any opportunity: My boss/rich uncle in Hong Kong/Taipei/Singapore has an organization of brothers dealing with timber/wildlife/money laundering/whatever. To gain credibility, he deploys stories of tiger bones and photos of pangolins taken from traffickers in other countries: “Then the boys feel comfortable and vouch for me to their friends. Gradually, over the months and years, it makes its way to the pivots.
Last year, Billy began visiting Costa Rica and, through hard paintings in restaurants and beauty salons, met nine “persons of interest. “Costa Rica was not an apparent target for ELI. It has perhaps the best-run government in Central America and has asked the UN to elevate a wildlife industry protocol to its bans on human and firearms trafficking. But there was an explanation for why locals were exporting significant quantities of shark fins. The biologist who worked with ELI analyzed the shipping documents and decided that shark fins from Costa Rica were entering Hong Kong at a rate ten times higher than the officially identified rate.
ELI had earned one hundred thousand dollars from a two-year grant limited to Costa Rica. (Crosta’s global agenda, to his dismay, has to be carried out in one country or species at a time. )For researchers, Latin America poses specific challenges. Crawford Allan, Senior Director of Wildlife Crime at W. W. F. The United States told me: “In Africa, the elephant crisis was evident: you have huge animals with their faces cut off and someone filling a container full of ivory. In Latin America, it is much more hidden This is someone who takes a boat to a remote position in the jungle 3 times a week.
Earlier this year, Crosta and Davis and their criminal analyst, Chiara Talerico, a fiercely intelligent Italian, were completing a fried rice lunch in San Jose, Costa Rica’s capital, when Billy texted from next door. He had finished talking to Mr. Lin, a local black market stalwart, and going “across the street” to a seafood store to talk about exporting fins. The team scoured the city’s Chinatown for fifteen minutes, looking for a “big red sign” that Billy said marked the store. It turned out to be 4 blocks and just around the corner. “Across the street, my butt! Crosta grommela.
After Billy’s appearance, the team gathered in the lobby of a Marriott, next to a sign that read “Please Don’t Feed Coatis. “here from Puntarenas” — to the city on the coast — “and some come from the United States. “
copied link
“It’s weird,” Crosta said.
Billy shrugged: Everything is super weird. The global killing of sharks is huge: humans kill a hundred million a year, and it’s short-sighted. Sharks affect the environment in two very important ways: they help maintain phytoplankton populations (which produce some of the oxygen we breathe) by eating their predators. , and help maintain the ocean as the world’s largest carbon sink by removing animals that remove carbon from the air. Most of the sharks we kill are unwanted catches, but we also use their teeth as jewelry, their meat as puppy food, their cartilage and liver oil as moisturizers in sunscreen and lipstick, and their fins for soup.
As a tropical rain drummed on the roof of the hotel, Billy began to draw a network of shoppers and contacts. There, Mr. Lin: “a short, overweight guy who wears crazy clothes. “On his phone, he scrolled through a picture of Lin, wearing a gold brocade jacket worthy of Admiral Gilbert and Sullivan. There Diego, a local businessman who had taken Billy to a trafficker named Pascal, and who had also promised to put him in touch with Mario, a mythical exporter of shark fins. .
Talerico, who had frowned on his laptop, said: “Okay, I found out Diego’s Skype and WhatsApp information!Let’s put it here on my map, it makes it more enjoyable. Is he, shall we say, a visitor to Mario? »
“Diego in the business,” Billy said, “but he’d like a commission. “
“I would love to do a network analysis,” he continued, “but we want at least 3 other people to create a network. “Once Talerico knows the basics of a network, it runs software visualizing the traffickers’ phone records and identifies the group’s “secret keeper” or key intermediary. Then, it executes a set of vector centrality rules of its own to reveal the final boss, the user connecting to the secret keeper, and no one else.
It is a nebulous and inferential work. A trafficking network is almost never the hierarchical “nexus image” described in the police program. A forensic scientist named Sam Wasser, who consults with national security, conducted a DNA investigation on forty-nine ivory shipments seized in Africa between 2002 and 2019. By collecting the genetic matches between the defenses and correlating those effects with phone records and transportation expenses, Wasser concluded that no more than four teams of transnational thieves shipped most of the ivory out of Africa. However, he told me, “over and over again, you think you have the shaft and then you see ivory coming out that has the same characteristics and connection points. “
That night in San Jose, Billy went out to dinner with Pascal; the ELI team sitting at a table ten meters away. Talerico looked over and whispered, “Pascal brought his family. His parents took shrimp and corn out of a pot. “head: “Pascal will communicate business. “
Billy later said Pascal, unfazed by his parents’ presence, had freely discussed a series of “suspicious transactions,” adding mercury smuggling used in wild mines to separate gold from other minerals. “And he told me there were some secret gold mines. “in southern Costa Rica, near the border with Panama. Maybe next time they can take me to the golden guy.
Crosta’s method has worked remarkably well, at least as far as surveys are concerned. As of 2021, after two years in Bolivia, ELI knew a lot about a jaguar tusk trafficking network there; the teeth, bought from poachers for twenty-two dollars each, sold for nine hundred dollars in China and Vietnam, where they were classified as tiger tusks. Pauline Verheij, a Dutch scholar, had written a considered report on trafficking in Bolivia and Suriname in 2019, based on open-source studies and interviews with local police. But he told me ELI’s techniques revealed “much more detailed data on how those networks operate. “
Crosta shared his data with a prosecutor named Moises Palma Salazar, who heads Bolivia’s environmental crimes office. Police searched six properties, arrested 4 Chinese nationals, and recovered 16 reptile belts and 4 jaguar tusks. But there was a leak: A few months later, as a new investigation began, a WeChat message addressed to the trafficking network warned everyone to take cover. When Billy returned that year, a hitman he met at a party told him about other texts detailing precisely what the police were looking for. Billy said: “Luckily it’s my fourth or fifth time in Bolivia. If it was the first time, they would have suspected me.
For a while, the network behaved as Crosta expected: the traffickers told Billy he could no longer sell. But business temporarily recovered. Palma told me that even if he gets convictions, the defendant faces sentences of up to seven years, and probably far from that. The Bolivian police, which has only about fifty environmental police, do not speak Chinese and are sometimes overwhelmed. ELI has been able to get close to those networks,” he said.
In 2018, it began sharing data with the Mexican government about the cartel of the sea. But a prosecutor who worked on the case told me that the sea cucumber case opposed to the cartel stalled. In the similar totoaba cases, a Chinese citizen arrested but not prosecuted, and the first Mexican to be acquitted.
Crosta and Davis had spent a lot of time in Baja, and ELI had produced a comprehensive report on the bladder industry and its effects on vaquitas, which get caught in fishermen’s gillnets. The population was over five hundred and sixty-seven in 1997 to about eight. However, not only did the traffickers go unpunished, but the vaquita’s story was seized. Sea Shepherd, an NGO that had stationed surveillance ships in the Upper Gulf of California since 2015, claimed in a fundraising email last summer that its paintings were having a “measurable and positive effect on the vaquita,” a story that is not one of disappearance but of resilience.
The more the vaquita is perceived to flourish, the more money NGOs can make from it. But Lorenzo Rojas-Bracho, a marine biologist who has long overseen the Mexican government’s efforts to save porpoises, told me that local incentives happen the other way around. Some governments say the vaquita is going to disappear, and maybe they even need to,” he said. “As long as the vaquita is there, fishermen are angry at the national government for banning them from fishing, and the national government faces foreign pressure and sanctions. The saying we have is “Once the dog is dead, the rabies passes. ” »
Time is running out. ” I dreamed of the last vaquita,” Crosta told me. “I was at sea in a boat, and I saw a little head coming out of the water, and he was calling the others, they’re very sociable. “- But no one answered. And I was very sad. It would be the first species protected through CITES to disappear, an epic conservation failure. He laughs, abruptly. ” I say, ‘Epic failure of conservation. ‘”
After those experiences, Crosta said, he realized, “We can’t pass with the Bolivian environmental police or the Ecuadorian forest police, Jesus Christ!Now he would only bring his juiciest morsels to American law enforcement. Ultimately, he hoped to identify “an earth intelligence enterprise” modeled on the C. I. A. and its global reach. ” He would be a pariah in the NGO. community,” he told me. They were saying, ‘What Andrea is doing creates problems of lack of transparency, corrupts locals as informants and puts them at risk, blah, blah, blah. ‘Traffickers to do what they do is zero.
Crosta’s tireless zeal wreaked havoc. In 2014 he married Nirmala Fernandes, a Dutch model, but the marriage did not last; she left for Los Angeles in 2018 and they filed for divorce. “The paintings Andrea made in that dark world overshadowed him,” Fernandes said. “I was preparing dinner and heard those terrible sounds while watching a video of tortured gorillas. . Laughter and joy with his friends, all this vanished. People think it would have saved our marriage if Andrea had painted less, but it would leave him too dissatisfied not to do everything he can for animals. I don’t even think he’d like to be called human anymore. More like a wolf.
Puntarenas, on Costa Rica’s west coast, bears the imprint of illicit globalization. Mexican and Colombian cartels transport cocaine, and outdoors the domain where cruise ships dock briefly, houses have window bars, docks are closed and foreigners are subject to scrutiny. When the ELI team visited the port of Caldera, just south of Puntarenas, two ships were loading boxes, a gantry crane making quick and relentless paintings, and nine others were waiting in the bay. “It’s the best small port for smuggling,” Crosta said. If you pay a user there, you can do whatever you want. “
However, for days, evidence for Crosta’s conclusions had been scarce. Billy met a successful resident, Victoria, who had hinted that she could sell him seahorses and sea dragons. But she was suspicious, “a little order with her and her husband,” he told the team later at a beach restaurant. A black-tailed iguana rested on a pile of concrete blocks nearby, perfectly camouflaged.
“We were hoping Victoria could introduce you to something bigger,” Talerico said, frowning at his graph of skeletal connections.
“The big one wouldn’t introduce you to anyone, because that’s the big one,” Billy said.
Two days later, Billy announced that he had discovered a much less suspicious one. In the lobby of the team’s hotel, he showed photos he had taken of a mansion owned by a seafood exporter named Joshua. “Dude, this guy’s space is beautiful!” He said.
“Joshua is who, exactly?” Taleric said irritably. I want you to start at the beginning.
Billy introduced a detailed narrative: he was hoping to see Mario, the mythical exporter, but Mario refused to meet strangers, so Diego picked him up at his canopy hotel and took him to meet Joshua and his wife. For several hours at home, then in Glenfiddich at a nearby restaurant, Joshua explained his shark fin operation. Billy released a shaky video of clothing baskets filled with fins of silky sharks and thresher sharks, which have an export quota; hammerhead sharks, which cannot be exported; and oceanic sharks, which is even illegal to board a boat. “That’s the missing piece: the visual,” Crosta said. He squeezed Billy’s arm. ” So many wonderful main points that wouldn’t be in the transcript!I’m very happy. ” Billy blinked. Previously, he told me, “Andrea and I have never had a beer together in 4 or five years. There is no verbal exchange between friends.
Billy said: “Most of those fins, in addition to hammerhead sharks, are trapped in Costa Rican waters as they get bigger south to reach Cocos Island. Good tourist position for snorkeling. “
copied link
“OfArray of Array,” Crosta said. From them they take hammerhead sharks in Cocos Island National Park. “
Joshua then told Billy about a ploy triggered through abusive officials, the kind of foreign bribery that could interest national security. Joshua travels to Nicaragua to collect fins, as well as cocobolo, a CITES-protected tree with a ruvian-colored heartwood. deposits 300 dollars at customs at the border, and fifteen hundred dollars more to slide the cargo on a ship in Caldera, without inspection. “out of the country. He told me, “They started smuggling cocobolo through Costa Rica because the Nicaraguan government confiscated seventy boxes. These boxes were then sold to China through ‘” – named a front man in Nicaragua.
Talerico moved among the piles of files on his desk, typing quickly. “Sometimes if I have a stroke, we’re all screwed,” he muttered.
Crosta said: “That’s when it starts to get interesting. Let’s take a look at money, networks, shipping, paperwork.
“Diego was doing his best to translate all this Spanish for me,” Billy said. “As we were leaving, Joshua’s wife said, ‘Diego, you deserve to pay us, because you’re learning so much about the company. ‘”. ‘”
Everyone smiled. ” I couldn’t have asked for anything better!” said Crosta. Can we say now that those guys are the top 3 shark fin traffickers: Mario, Joshua, Victoria and her husband?
Mark Davis satisfied but suspicious. He later told me, “If we had cash in the overall budget, we would do 3 times as many operations here and find five times as many people to prosecute. “
The tusks of a giant bull elephant can fetch upwards of $400,000 on the underground market. Most environmental organizations hope to replace our attitude so that we don’t see elephants as a liquid asset, like inventory or a bond, but rather as a non-liquid asset, like a mountain view. However, for some conservationists, the only way to save animals is to finance them. By one estimate, this same bull elephant, if left alive, could contribute $23,000 a year to his home country’s tourism revenue. Ralph Chami, deputy director of the International Monetary Fund, suggests that animals, by maintaining ecosystems, are already saving us a fortune. According to his calculations, this elephant’s carbon sequestration facility generates $2. 6 million for him. A blue whale, which acts like equivalent paintings in the ocean, costs at least 3 million. Chami told me: “People of nature’s intrinsic price, your arrogance is actively helping to destroy nature. My audience is made up of other people I care about, so I have to speak to them in a language they understand: “Elephants are quietly saving your ass, so how about you pay them a salary?” »
Chami advocates for a framework that works like carbon credits. Charities and corporations would buy carbon offsets, like Chile’s blue whales, and the money would help maintain the aquatic ecosystem. Chami said the real heroes of marine systems are seagrass beds and phytoplankton. , however, he said: “We have an affinity for whales. The same goes for elephants: a baby elephant melts your center in two seconds. A thorny challenge is that carbon credits have proven to be vaporous: The Guardian recently decided that many rainforest offsets are “ghost credits” whose acquisition brings no benefit to the environment. Also, while some animals help sequester carbon (yes, otters and wildebeest!), others do the opposite (boo, sea urchins!). In the Chami system, we would decide on the trophy species to value, just as traffickers do.
The biggest challenge with financialization methods is that no amount of investment can avoid the greatest risk to: the human population, which is expected to grow by about ten billion through 2050. More other people will mean more contact and more clash with animals. Matt Morley, who runs IFAW’s anti-crime program, told me, “Because we’ve been successful in controlling poaching, there are now spaces where more elephants are being killed because of efforts to mitigate human-elephant clashes. “, in reserves in northern Kenya, hunters have killed 3 elephants for their ivory and one hundred and thirty for trampling crops and livestock. The answer, which we discovered in Europe and North America, where we wiped out all our charismatic megafauna long ago, is no.
ELI’s partnerships with U. S. agencies have yet to have the transformative effect Crosta had hoped for. This winter, he informed Fish and Wildlife about two shipments of seafood from Joshua’s company in Costa Rica to the United States. The agency’s inspectors didn’t discover anything suspicious. “I guess those other people don’t send illegal things,” Crosta said. “Or maybe the inspectors didn’t notice. ” (Shark fins that have been processed, bleached, dried and peeled, look like noodles. )Meanwhile, Mark Davis understood from Fish and Wildlife that, later this month, the government would arrest a known trafficker through ELI. Homeland Security also promised arrests, faster or later. Crosta was still betting that his targets would eventually be charged with more serious crimes and yet he would not back down for money laundering or human trafficking, but for wildlife trafficking. sea cucumber that they gave us in trouble,” he admitted.
Will the strength of the U. S. government replace the equation?In 2017, Moazu Kromah, one of the main ivory traffickers, arrested in Uganda; The ivory on their expeditions came from elephants in seven countries. But he was soon released on bail. Then Fish and Wildlife and the Drug Enforcement Administration got involved. Kromah was extradited to the United States and last year pleaded guilty to trafficking at least ten tons of ivory and one hundred and 90 pounds of rhino horn to Asia and the United States. tactics at most a successful prosecution of a transnational criminal organization. But his sentence, only sixty-three months, or about what he can serve on the federal formula to traffic 4 ounces of heroin, evidently did not deter wildlife crime. “Kromah’s network has reformed around the others and the corruption is still going on,” Morley told me. “We have a guy in Uganda in our sights, a branch of Kromah, but can we move his business forward there?Very difficult. “
Even extinctions only displace trade. The eels, which are used in soup and eaten on the grill as unagi, can sell for twenty-seven thousand dollars consistent with the kilo in Japan. Because the Asian elvers were caught, traffickers now bring mules from Europe in suitcases containing hidden water tanks. , with controlled temperature and constant oxygen and nature levels. Demand is also constantly evolving, inversely to herbal selection. In southern and central Africa, Vietnamese bands now compete with Chinese ones. (breaking transactions into sets small enough for surveillance) and “layers” (creating a bewildering pile of corporations to process transactions).
“I have no illusions that law enforcement alone will prevent wildlife trafficking,” said Phil Alegranti, a senior official with Fish and Wildlife. “Efforts to raise global awareness come with a crusade for the International Criminal Court to treat ‘ecocide’ as an atrocity in terms of war crimes and genocide. However, traffickers may not be highly motivated through ethical persuasion. “of the Department of Homeland Security’s nascent wildlife and environmental crime unit, said: “Andrea is into anything with the concept that you can scare other people who have ‘legitimate’ businesses to protect. Fans can scare them, and there are many. But the Central Boys will be encouraged to pick up the slack.
Crosta told me: “What helps me stay up at night is that I am surrounded by other irreplaceable people: Billy, Mark, Chiara, all exclusive themes of failure. Besides, my task is definitely more complicated than I thought. When he and I started talking last summer, ELI’s global list of other high-level persons of interest contained one hundred and two names. He is now one hundred and seventy-two, and the capos selling in China remain unidentified.
In March, Crosta became a U. S. citizen and has a new relationship with an intensive care nurse named Sofya. He promised to be with her each and every full moon, even if she has to leave a convention to go home. Since his divorce, he says, he has had a recurring vision of himself in the form of a wolf at the edge of a forest: “There is a long meadow on the border, and beyond, there are houses, lights, women and food. And I think, Ooh, it has to be warm and comfortable. But crossing the prairie was impossible. It was the worry of feeling, because if you feel like you’re screwed. Together with Sofya, he said: “I have become fully aware that I needed the kind of warmth you can only get from humans, from time to time. “
On a global scale, this same challenge – controlling impulses – has enormous consequences for our species. If we can’t go beyond our intuition to conquer nature, there may not be much left to conquer. I don’t give a damn about all those other clever concepts: tourism dollars and cheap price and everything. Yes, but they are at the bottom of my list. In order for us to save animals, we will have to be bigger than we are. Because wildlife has a right to exist, no matter how economically valuable it is, no matter how useful it is to us in some way. It’s the same idea I’ve had since I was five years old: animals are our family. They are my family. ” ♦
An earlier part of this article mischaracterized Nir Kalron’s role in launching Elephant Action League.
First it scandalized Washington, then a princess.
The meanings of the Muslim veil.
What exactly happened between Neanderthals and humans?
The outcome of a serial killer.
When you eat a dried fig, you also chew wasp mummies.
The slippery scams of the olive oil industry.
Classic Reviews: Our 1991 Review of “Thelma”
Subscribe to our newsletter for the most productive stories from The New Yorker.
By registering, you agree to our Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement.
By Jason Diamante
By Danielle Ofri
By Colin Marshall
Sections
Further
© 2023 Condé Nast. All rights reserved. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement and your California Privacy Rights. The New Yorker would likely earn a share of sales of products purchased on our site as part of our component partnerships associated with retailers. Materials on this Site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used unless you have the prior written permission of Condé Nast. Ad Choices