Across China, rare mass protests against the country’s strict COVID pandemic protocols have multiplied, with demonstrators in many cities taking to the streets to vent their frustrations.
While protests are completely unknown in China, those that do occur tend to be location- or problem-specific, from staff pay hikes that aren’t easy to homebuyers denouncing backlogged housing projects. And a physically powerful surveillance infrastructure and immediate responses from the state. Forces regularly nip them in the bud before they can spread. This time is already different, although it is unlikely to determine precisely how many of China’s 1. 4 billion people participated.
The obvious catalyst was the chimney of an apartment that killed at least 10 other people in Urumqi, the capital of the northwestern region of Xinjiang, last Thursday. Suggestions that COVID measures have emergency services behind have sparked a wave of public unrest like no other.
President Xi Jinping’s zero-COVID technique has kept infections at bay in China, yet the prolonged isolation and regulated mobility it entails has been increasingly shunned by the public and has even been blamed for several recent high-profile tragedies. Officials deny it COVID policies are to blame for victims of the Urumqi fire.
Read more: China’s 0 COVID Policy Emerging Prices
As China watches the rest of the world open up, frustration grows over its own harsh and disruptive measures against the pandemic. Those who mock or criticize the measures have been beaten or arrested. Despite this, protests against COVID-0 continue to multiply in major cities. , adding the capital Beijing and the monetary center of Shanghai.
Complaints about testing and quarantine needs that came to a head over the weekend also morphed into blatant opposition to Xi and the ruling Chinese Communist Party. “We don’t need a leader, we need votes,” protesters chanted Sunday in Beijing dressed in white. White sheets, a new symbol of resistance. In Hanghai, protesters called on Xi and the CCP to step aside and apologize.
It remains to be noted that this discontent will challenge the strength of the ruling party, but “the fact that [existing mass protests] have even lodged in the repressive political environment itself suggests that public discontent has reached the tipping point,” Yanzhong Huang said. , senior researcher for global fitness at the Council on Foreign Relations, says TIME.
Here’s what you want to know about the protests rocking China.
According to the Associated Press, protests against COVID-0 have been reported in at least 8 major cities across the country.
In Shanghai, a crowd of citizens gathered for a candlelight vigil on Urumqi Road on Saturday night to mourn the victims of the Xinjiang fire. The vigil turned into a protest when, according to CNN, the crowd shouted “I don’t need a COVID test, I need freedom!”, while others held banners denouncing strict pandemic protocols. The protest continued until the next day and several other people reportedly continued to appear at the protest site on Monday.
The Guardian reports about 1,000 more people piled up on a road near the Liangma River, brandishing blank sheets of paper and singing, refusing to disperse until the wee hours of Monday morning.
People have also reportedly gathered at universities to show their disapproval of zero-COVID measures. The videos on social media, which TIME may simply not verify, allegedly show academics from the University of Communication of China in Nanjing gathering for a vigil similar to the one in Shanghai. Some protesters also piled up at Peking University and Tsinghua University in Beijing, based on social media posts. The Communist Party has a sensitive point for universities, as the Tiananmen Square protests of 1989 were led by academics.
Read more: How China’s Tiananmen Square Bloodbath Forever
Huang, a senior researcher at the CFR, says the protests have not yet “reached a national level. “As for its scale, observers agree that it is difficult to predict, but it turns out that the protests are increasingly organized. Jean-Pierre Cabestan, professor emeritus of political science at Hong Kong Baptist University, told TIME that protesters are starting to use the same messages at all protests, many of which echo the language of a viral protest banner last month. the protest has much more politics,” he told TIME.
COVID-0 protests have been going on for months, but researchers at the rights organization Freedom House noticed an increase since September. Kevin Slaten, research manager for the organization’s China Dissent Monitor project, says one thing unique about the most recent protests is that the Urumqi chimney also has a “galvanizing” force for citizens in other cities. He says critics relied on hashtags, intended to spread data about the fireplace on Chinese social media, to express anger and anger at the authorities’ handling of the apartment tragedy. .
“It wasn’t so much with the [past] COVID-19 protests,” Slaten told TIME.
Urumqi had been blocked since August and, as a result, transport was disrupted. With the lockdown, Xinjiang has controlled to decrease COVID-19 cases, at one point, even to single digits. However, by October, daily infections in the region had resurrected, dashing hopes of reopening.
But the fatal fire in a high-rise building, which also injured nine people, took only about 3 hours to faint, Bloomberg reports. Residents and users took to social media to denounce the authorities’ delayed emergency response, blaming zero-COVID restrictions in place. Officials eventually apologized and on Saturday promised to lift restrictions “in an orderly manner,” but by that point protests had already spread to other cities.
As an authoritarian state, China is doubling down on its acts of dissent. Chinese censors are also quick to remove any mention of online protests, a not unusual reaction to threats opposing one-party rule. Videos and images of the existing wave of protests have already been removed from Chinese social media.
In Hanghai, Chinese police confronted protesters, pepper sprayed and beat several of them. AFP videos showed police detaining others on Monday at the site of the Shanghai protests, after the crowd collapsed. installed where the protests had damaged.
According to a BBC statement, Ed Lawrence, one of his bloodhounds covering the Shanghai protests, was arrested and later released. The media organization’s spokesman expressed fear over Lawrence’s treatment, saying he had been “punched and kicked” by police.
“Until recently, most Chinese were very afraid of the efficacy and scale of China’s repressive organs and didn’t lift a finger,” says Cabestan. But recent protests show how other people are “fed up with the existing scenario and think things will change. “
However, on Monday night, the AP reported that the government’s reaction to the protests had generally been muted. But dragging Xi’s call to the protests has security implications. “People know it’s a red line,” Slaten told TIME. “The repression will be accentuated if you touch things like this. “
To some extent, the protests have already yielded results: the government has eased some of the COVID restrictions in Urumqi, as well as Beijing and Guangzhou.
But the Chinese government has been so silent about the mass protests, and only reinforced through state media the importance of maintaining zero-COVID measures.
As for whether the protests can force the Chinese government to end its 0 COVID strategy anytime soon, experts say it’s not likely.
Read more: China just eased some pandemic measures, but experts recommend ‘zero-COVID’ disappear soon
Some concessions can be made, depending on China’s confidence in its ability to “crush any discontent in the streets,” says Freedom House’s Laten.
For Huang, much of the anger expressed is directed at Xi, the central government could try to quell social unrest by punishing some local officials “as they have done before,” he said, referring to how local officials were forced to resign earlier. . this year for failing to manage outbreaks in their jurisdictions.
Still, Chinese citizens’ lack of herbal immunity and doubts about the efficacy of their locally produced vaccines raise fears that any opening initiative could deal a severe blow to China.
On Monday, China recorded a new record for COVID-19 infections, with more than 40,000 new cases.
“The government can still implement policies to quell protests, but the easing of the policy will be followed through an immediate backlog of cases, an end result that the most sensible policymaker probably wouldn’t want to see,” Huang said.