Stay connected
CNBC examines how global positions have approached Covid-19. By talking to a wide variety of experts, as well as citizens, we take an inventory of what went well and what didn’t.
Brazil has shown more than 2.1 million cases of Covid-19 and more than 80,000 deaths in a population of approximately 209 million. Brazil’s 100,000-capita mortality rate is among those in the world. Brazil has struggled to cope with the lack of evidence, enthusiasts and beds of extensive attention in many regions, and its lack of knowledge has made it difficult to understand the temporary way in which the virus is spreading. Dozens of fitness staff died after being inflamed by the virus. The interior of the country is now consistent with what is considered vulnerable.
By comparison, the United States, with approximately 330 million people, recorded more than 3.9 million and 143,000 deaths.
Basic community efforts
Residents say many low-income neighborhoods in Brazil, such as favelas, have let themselves fend for themselves in relation to Covid-19.
But some took on issues in their own hands. In Paraisopolis, Sao Paulo’s largest slum, so-called street citizens helped their neighbors get food, fitness care and other necessities, and citizens switched a public school to an area for others who had tested positive for the virus.
But elsewhere, the virus continued to spread relentlessly. Social estrangement, especially in Brazil’s poorest regions, is almost a challenge.
“We have many deficient families living in small houses with space for everyone, which makes it almost a social estrangement,” said Dr. Larissa Fogaca Doretto, a researcher at the Federal University of Sao Paulo. In the state, other people of color are 62% more likely to die of Covid-19 than their white counterparts.
Coordination between public and hospitals
In Sao Paulo, Brazil’s largest city, public hospitals at the height of the pandemic were approaching capacity. To widespread chaos, the most productive personal hospitals have begun to operate heavily with hospitals in the city’s poorest neighborhoods for percentage of their resources, materials and expertise. Municipal and public fitness agencies, in collaboration with the personal sector, have also contributed to the opening of hospital beds.
Dr. Sidney Klajner, president of the Albert Einstein Jewish Hospital in Sao Paulo, noted that there has been much more coordination in recent months. Her physical care formula has donated alcohol, masks and face protectors to more than a hundred hospitals in low-income spaces to help healthcare workers. It’s also ready early for the pandemic. “We were able to turn almost three hundred beds into Covid,” he said.
However, in other parts of Brazil, public hospitals have been further affected by the virus and are suffering from enough beds and extensive care enthusiasts, while hospitals treating richer patients have beds to lose. Many call for a national or federal policy to coordinate the response.
Telemedicine
“Telemedicine was practiced slightly in Brazil,” said Emilio Puschmann, founder of Amparo, a number one telemedicine and care provider founded in the country. “There were some vendors in operation, but it was difficult.”
Now, he says, the Department of Health has given soft green to some virtual medicine bureaucracy to allow doctors to see patients at home.
“With Covid-19, everything changed,” Puschmann said. But he said more quality controls are needed so that low-quality players don’t rush to market. “Everyone creates software and it’s hard for payers to distinguish between smart and bad.”
Several responses from state governments.
In Brazil, states have mobilized to manage the Covid-19 response. Other richer people with more resources, such as Sao Paulo, tended to perform better than others. And across Brazil, the mortality rate tends to be higher in poorer cities than in richer cities.
In the poorest spaces, such as the Amazonian town of Manaus, the stage has reached a critical point. There, in a cemetery, thousands of other people from remote spaces were buried in collective pits after their death while seeking treatment. Now, considerations are being developed on the South.
Dr. Luisane Vieira, a clinical pathologist from Brazil, explained: “We believe that the pandemic is heading south, where winter is colder, and to small towns, most of them do not have extensive care units, as needed.”
Financial aid
At the end of March, Economy Minister Paulo Guedes announced that Brazil’s vulnerable maximum staff would get a monthly pay cut of about real six hundred (about $118). It made a difference, the locals say, even if it wasn’t perfectly distributed. According to reports at the end of May, long queues have formed to access the rescue.
This is even more complicated for rural residents, who face the threat of coronavirus exposure when they go to cities, wait in a busy row and return home. It is not known whether this relief will continue and for how long.
Failed response
Brazil had many prospects for managing Covid-19 well, experts say, but it has failed. Instead, President Jair Bolsonaro has downplayed the virus, even as cases continue to rise.
“Brazil has lost an intelligent opportunity to the pandemic,” said Dr. Paulo Lotufo, director of the Center for Clinical and Epidemiological Research at the University of Sao Paulo, Brazil. “During the time of March week, Brazil was well positioned to initiate social isolation, Array … and the reaction of the population has been incredible. (But) 10 days later, Bolsonaro went out on national television to tell his followers to boycott the isolation. , saying it was just a little flu.”
Earlier this month, Bolsonaro himself was diagnosed with Covid-19.
Confusion and misinformation
Health ministers have not held office for long since the start of the pandemic. Dr. Nelson Teich, an oncologist, surrenders in late May after a month. He had replaced Luiz Henrique Mandetta, who dismissed the president in April after a series of disagreements over the pandemic.
Brazilians say things haven’t replaced much since Bolsonaro was diagnosed with coronavirus, and the message remains confusing for many people.
“In fact, we are not well located in Brazil,” said Natasha Vianna, a Brazilian founded in San Francisco. “It was the Health Ministers who did an intelligent task encouraging others to stay home and wear masks.”
With the conversion of the guard, and the constant minimization of the virus at the federal point, Brazilians say the rules are as consistent as they could have been.
“We don’t have transparent policies,” said Dr. Cristiano Englert, an anesthesiologist and co-founder of a start-up accelerator in Brazil. “And we may have just been more prepared.”
“A lot of this is aligned with politics,” added Gary Monk, a British fitness representative who founded the pandemic in Brazil. “Some take it seriously and some are quite relaxed, and there are camps for and against masks.”
Lack of coverage for fitness workers
Covid-19 was temporarily extended among fitness workers, with evidence indicating that they were disproportionately affected by the pandemic. Dr. Antonio Bandeira, director of the Brazilian Society of Infectious Diseases, estimates that in some areas, up to 10% of other people diagnosed with the virus were fitness workers.
According to the researchers, one of the main disorders in Brazil is the lack of protective and training equipment. Nurses, in particular, contracted the disease and died faster than in the world, according to a report released last May.
Lack of evidence
Brazil is doing enough testing, according to its public fitness officials and doctors.
“Brazil is recently testing in about a third of neighboring countries like Peru and Chile, which are not doing enough,” said Michael Touchton, assistant professor of political science at the University of Miami, who helped build a tracker for Covid-19 in the Americas. Without testing the data, it is very difficult for the medical formula to reduce exposure and anticipate the potential shortage of the source chain. In addition, citizens agree that it is much less difficult for other richer people to access the tests through the driving service centers.
“We have a good enough program of molecular testing and tactile studies to isolate patients and patients with COVID-19,” Vieira said. “We are among the countries of the world that have proven the least.”
Treatment of indigenous peoples.
“The Aboriginal is in a desperate situation,” Touchton said.
As he explained, there was not enough medical care for others in poor health. And the New York Times reports that limiting communities through the federal government would probably have done more harm than good. The report indicates that thousands of others probably stuck the virus originally through medical staff who were sent to those remote spaces without good enough protective equipment. At least 500 aboriginal people, other people have died since the onset of the pandemic.
The response — or lack thereof — to Indigenous people is part of a broader policy of neglect toward the region.
“The administration has become a cornerstone of its environmental policy to exploit and reach through the jungle,” Touchton said.
Vulnerable population without physical care
In theory, Brazil may have been created to succeed. Its fitness system, SUS, serves about 80 percent of the population.
But this formula is surpassed by the virus. The lack of application of the mask and social estrangement is especially problematic, according to experts, when the fitness formula is not designed to serve a large influx of people with bad physical shape. This becomes even more complicated with the higher proportion of others with pre-existing conditions, putting them at greater risk.
“Many other people don’t have access to number one care,” Klajner said. “They don’t take the right medications for their upper blood pressure and diabetes, and the fitness care system considers them too late.”
Increases hydroxychloroquine
The Brazilian fitness government has boosted hydroxychloroquine, an unproven antimalarial drug, despite growing clinical evidence that it is not effective as a remedy for coronavirus.
U.S. President Donald Trump praised the drug and said at one point that he took it as a precautionary measure. Bolsonaro also approved hydroxychloroquine, even posting a video of himself washing it with water after pointing out that he had become inflamed with the virus.
Reviewers at Bolsonaro expressed fear that this behavior will inspire more people to take the drug and resist precautions to get sick.
We asked all the experts we talked to about your score on 10. (1 is the excessive mediocre and 10 is ideal). This is an overly subjective measure, but the average of 3.
“I would give the company reaction a nine or even a 10,” said Bandeira, the infectious disease expert. “And I would give many states a higher number. But I would give the federal government a 1 or a 2.”
“I’d give a 2 to Brazil, there’s a country in the Americas that’s done worse, and that’s Nicaragua,” Touchton said. “At least in Brazil, state and municipal administrations have assumed duty and tried to fill the void.”
With more reports from Michelle Gao
Do you have any confidential information? We have to hear from you.
Sign up for loose newsletters and get more CNBC in your inbox
Get it in your inbox and more information about our services.
© 2020 CNBC LLC. All rights are reserved. An NBCUniversal department
Knowledge is a real-time snapshot: the data is delayed by at least 15 minutes. Global industry and monetary news, inventory quotes and market knowledge and analysis.
Data also by