Log in
Join Now
A room full of second-graders spent a recent fall morning learning about an authoritarian mother named “Mama E” who follows her children by reminding them to say their names.
The fantasy tale component of a phonetics lesson at Bradley International School in Denver. The fact that adding an “e” to the end of a word adjusts the first vowel from short to long; For example, PIN becomes PIN because the “i” says its name.
Teacher Megan Bobroske challenged the young men sitting side by side on a rainbow-striped carpet in front of her: Can Mama E live at the beginning of the word instead of at the end?A little boy named Peter said, “She will have to be at the end of the word. “He said, “Imagine if she’s on the front line, she’ll be too busy saying her name. “
Peter and his classmates were informed of a rule about the English language that they applied over and over again that day, reading and writing “hope,” “cute,” “ribbon,” and “slide. “These classes reflect a district – and a statewide change in how young people are informed to read in Colorado.
Gone are reading systems that inspire young people to perceive what a jumble of letters says through image search or other clues to guess the word, a discredited strategy still used in some popular reading systems. Now, more emphasis is being placed on training the relationships between sounds and letters in a direct and conscientious sequenced manner. It is part of the science of reading, a vast framework of wisdom about how young people are taught to read.
Some are satisfied with the new reading systems being implemented in their schools, but there are also obstacles: confusing technology, new tactics for organizing students, or an overwhelming amount of material, to name a few.
The hope is that better training fabrics combined with a recent statewide instructor education effort will reshape reading instruction and improve reading outcomes in Colorado.
“They’re the big guys,” said Floyd Cobb, associate commissioner for student learning at the Colorado Department of Education.
But is that to drive statewide reading investment?And if so, when?
Cobb said the timeline isn’t clear, in part because curriculum changes are still underway in some districts and because the maximum immediate effects will be seen on K-3 reading tests administered by school districts than on state tests administered at the end of 3rd grade. Scores for those regime tests are not publicly published in a central location as are the effects of state tests.
This year, about 41 percent of Colorado’s third-graders scored at or above the state’s literacy tests, which combine reading and writing. of thousands of young people are suffering with fundamental literacy skills.
Krista Spurgin, executive director of Stand for Children Colorado, said she believes the state’s curriculum and instructor education projects have replaced the mindset about how reading is taught in Colorado.
“I hope that in a few years we will start to see the effects for third graders,” he said.
Colorado’s largest school districts, plus Denver, Jeffco, Douglas County, Cherry Creek and Aurora, are among those introducing a new reading curriculum. A state elementary reading law passed in 2019 pushed for the replacement by requiring schools to use science-based reading systems from kindergarten. through 3rd grade.
Previously, Colorado schools were allowed any reading program or none at all. There are now stricter barriers in place, though districts can still participate in more than a dozen core programs. A year ago, state officials began enforcing stricter program rules, ordering a multitude of districts to reposition unacceptable programs.
This resolution was unprecedented, and some districts backed down first, arguing that they were overlaying state-approved systems onto state-rejected systems. State officials did not give up.
The Bradley International sophomore knew something had to change in early 2021, even before state oversight came into play. His reading program at the time had major gaps in phonetics. clues and guessing what would make sense or just skipping the word,” Bobroske said.
The classes obviously did not enhance, and did not systematically read about, how letters and sounds work together. She said, for example, that students might have learned something from the “Mama E” rule, without understanding that a consonant sound will have to occur between the vowel and the “e” at the end of the word. This omission would lead scholars to misapply the rule and be frustrated when the words did not make sense.
“The academics didn’t have the equipment to break down the words and there was a lot of guesswork and hope that everything would go well,” he said.
Bradley’s sophomore team started the phonetic component of a new reading program, Core Knowledge Language Arts, and achieved impressive results. in reading.
“It’s crazy,” he said. In all honesty, I had never noticed anything like this happening before. “
In addition to better phonics, new reading systems in Denver and some other districts come with science and social studies sets designed to expand students’ fundamental wisdom about the world, a technique that helps students perceive what they read.
Molly Veliz, a Denver instructor who works with struggling readers at Marie L. Greenwood Early-8 said Core Knowledge Language Arts’ wisdom-reinforcement sets captured students’ attention.
“First-graders can tell me about the frame formula and how they paint in combination and [they] use the right vocabulary,” she said.
Ibeth Leon Ariza teaches at a bilingual immersion school in western Colorado where all elementary students are taught in English and Spanish. He claimed that the old reading curriculum included passages in Spanish that were not original translations and did not capture the meaning conveyed in the English version. . Leon Ariza, a local Spanish speaker from Colombia, has tried to correct those deficiencies by replacing a more suitable vocabulary or changing stories.
She doesn’t have to do it now. The new curriculum approved by the state district, Hacia la Lectura and its Spanish-language counterpart ¡Arriba La Lectura!, provides more content in Spanish.
About a portion of all Colorado students known as lower-grade reading degrees are also English learners, raising questions about whether schools stumble upon poor reading skills or limited English proficiency, and whether students have access to adequate instruction. A recent state audit of Colorado’s reading efforts reported disruptions and changes.
While Leon Ariza likes his district’s new reading program, which was introduced last year, there are also weaknesses. She finds that the online platform is difficult to navigate and said teachers can’t have compatibility with everything classes recommend in the daily reading block.
“We have difficulties with time,” he said.
Along with the inevitable learning curve that accompanies the new curriculum, many Colorado schools continue to face a multitude of demanding situations that have an effect on student learning, adding staff turnover, residual COVID disruptions, and circle of family stress. Rocky Mountain Elementary in Adams District 12 north of Denver is one of them.
“The ancient history of our school is that it has been chronically underperforming for about a decade. I’m their fourth director in 10 years,” said director Kate Vogel, who took the reins of the pandemic.
Last spring, only about 40% of students from kindergarten through grade 3 were particularly in reading. In addition, about a portion of students learn English and nearly 90% are entitled to subsidized meals, a measure of poverty.
On a recent morning in Megan Neitzel’s classroom, third-graders worked on writing a summary of “The Story of King Midas,” which was one of the stories in their new curriculum, Benchmark Advance 2022. For some students, it was easy. A woman shone through her account of Greek myth to a visitor, noting which component was the focus of the tale and explaining the king’s mischoice (she turned her daughter into gold).
Meanwhile, other young people were struggling. In a small organization gathered around a table around Neitzel, a boy asked “What is a set?”He also had trouble writing “castle”.
“Fly for it,” he said. “What do you hear?”
When the boy muttered a lack of response, she asked him to do so.
Neitzel likes the new curriculum so much: the way phonetics and vocabulary are taught and because her students are enthusiastic about reading. Some take home their colored notebooks to read passages to their younger siblings, he said.
Vogel believes the new curriculum, along with state-mandated reading and the district’s recent efforts to deepen reading standards, have made all the difference.
“I just think teachers perceive a lot more now than Array. . . We’re in the science of reading,” he said.
Some of Colorado’s biggest reading improvement efforts have only been underway for a few years, but the state’s internal and external evidence suggests they may eventually make a difference.
One promising case comes from Mississippi, where state officials introduced a series of reading projects a decade ago, adding training for instructors in reading science.
In 2013, the state was placed at the back of the package for fourth-grade reading achievement in a check called the National Assessment of Educational Progress. for the first time.
In Colorado, a literacy scholarship program introduced in 2012 has produced impressive advances in literacy in many attractive schools. The three-year awards were given to schools that agreed to revise reading instruction, the same types of levers (strict curriculum regulations and guidance for educators) that now apply statewide.
But profits faded after grants dried up, infrequently due to staff or director turnover. The program also said some teachers didn’t have the foundational reading science they needed to conduct the training and other supports they had gained through the grant.
But things are different today.
The vast majority of K-3 teachers in Colorado have earned state-mandated education on reading training. Several systems for preparing for outstanding teachers have reorganized their reading classes. And future number one school teachers will now have to pass a separate exam on reading training to get their state license.
The state has more on its to-do list, adding more reading category revisions to the instructor preparation program and launching new state mandates for elementary principals and instructors who work with struggling readers in grades 4 through 12.
Stand for Children’s Spurgin also believes that adding a free full-day kindergarten in 2019-20 and launching a free preschool for Colorado 4-year-olds next fall will help students’ reading skills.
For now, she is positive about the adjustments taking place in Colorado classrooms.
“We’ve talked to teachers who are already seeing innovations in their classrooms, which is stimulating,” he said.
Ann Schimke is a senior journalist at Chalkbeat and covers the issues of early formative and early literacy. Contact Ann at aschimke@chalkbeat. org.
Chalkbeat is a nonprofit news story covering educational settings in public schools.
© 2022 LongmontLeader