You may be using an unsupported or superseded browser. For the most productive experience imaginable, use the latest edition of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Microsoft Edge to view this website.
Our research found that Nationwide is the overall auto insurance company, with Erie, Travelers, and USAA also standing out. We analyzed the insurers found nationally for costs, policy options, claims processes, and complaints.
We look at car insurance costs, policy options, complaint data, and collision repair claims service. Our editorial content is influenced by advertisers. We use data-driven methodologies to compare insurance corporations so that all corporations compare equally. You can read more about our editorial rules and judging method below.
Nationwide inspired us with its combination of great rates and many helpful supplemental policy offerings. Their car insurance rates are competitive across the board for other driving records and ages. We also like the fact that there are few court cases about your car insurance.
More: National Car Insurance Review
Complaints
Nationwide complaint levels have declined over the past two years and have remained below the industry average.
Quality of Collision Repairs
Nationwide has consistently earned a C from repair specialists for its collision claims processes, indicating that its claims handling is average.
Nationwide auto insurance is available in 46 states and Washington, D. C. Not available in Alaska, Hawaii, Louisiana, or Massachusetts.
We love USAA for members of the military network because of its affordable car insurance for drivers of all types of driving records and other ages. You will need to be a member of the military, veteran, or a family member of the military to be eligible for USAA Auto Insurance and the company understands the wishes of this network.
More: USAA Auto Insurance Review
Complaints
The goal of USAA’s auto insurance court cases has advanced over the past three years. It went from being slightly above the industry average to just below.
Quality of Collision Repairs
USAA’s repair professional rating for its claims handling processes has declined over the past four years, resulting in a poor D rating in 2024.
USAA is available in all 50 states and Washington, D. C.
We chose Travelers because it offers decent rates overall for a variety of drivers, adding those who have tickets for haste or have caused an accident. It also offers many additional policy options, making it a smart choice when making price comparisons.
More: Traveler Car Insurance Review
Complaints
Travelers has had very few court cases over their auto insurance.
Quality of Collision Repairs
Travelers’ bug repair score has gone from C to C in the last two years. This note indicates that Travelers has a poor complaints procedure.
Traveler’s auto insurance is available in 42 states and Washington, D. C. Not available on:
We love Erie for its exceptional car insurance rates for drivers who have caused a twist of fate, as well as its affordable rates for most other driver profiles. We are also inspired by its highest score for its collision repair claims processes and its lowest point. of complaints.
More: Erie Car Insurance Review
Complaints
The importance of auto insurance court cases in Erie has fluctuated in recent years and lately is just below the industry average.
Quality of Collision Repairs
Erie has earned top marks from repair specialists for the past four years. This means that frame department stores find that Erie’s claims handling practices achieve safe quality repairs.
Erie is available in 12 states and Washington, D. C. :
We like Progressive because it offers the cheapest rates for drivers with DUIs among the corporations we evaluate. The complaint rate is also low, which makes up for its lackluster rates for smart drivers and those who have caused accidents.
Learn more: Progressive Insurance Review
Complaints
Progressive’s auto insurance complaint levels have always been below the industry average and have declined every year for the past three years.
Quality of Collision Repairs
Progressive has consistently earned a C for collision repair over the past 4 years, and their claims processes are not below average.
Progressivism can be achieved in all 50 states and Washington, D. C.
We like the fact that Geico offers relatively reasonable insurance for drivers with bad credit, whose rates are usually high. Geico also offers competitive pricing for many other types of drivers and for parents who include a young driver on their policies.
More: Geico Car Insurance Review
Complaints
Geico has remained consistent with the low number of court cases over the past three years.
Quality of Collision Repairs
Repair professionals at large frame stores across the country have always given Geico a C rating. Geico may comply with its claim remediation procedures.
Geico auto insurance is available in all 50 states and Washington, D. C.
We were inspired by the family reductions introduced through Westfield, which add a reduction for teen drivers and young adults who get their own auto insurance policy in Westfield. The target of court cases is also very low.
More: Westfield Car Insurance Review
Complaints
Westfield Auto Insurance has traditionally had a low number of court cases over its auto insurance, however, there have been no complaints over the past year.
Quality of Collision Repairs
Westfield has earned a respectable B rating from collision repair specialists for the past four years, which is an indicator of the quality of decent repair processes and policies.
Westfield offers auto insurance in 10 states:
We love Auto-Owners for its many features for new car owners. One of them is your “acquisition value guarantee,” which will pay you the original acquisition value if your car is destroyed within the first two years. Another option is “General Loss of a New Car,” which replaces an entire vehicle with a new one if the loss occurs within 90 days of acquiring your vehicle.
More: Auto Insurance Review for Car Owners
Complaints
Automobiles have consistently won fewer court cases than the industry average over the past 3 years.
Quality of Collision Repairs
Car owners’ accident repair score has dropped over the past two years, from B to B, but it’s still a wonderful score and indicates that they have smart repair practices in place.
Auto insurance for car owners is available in 26 states:
Our research shows that Nationwide, USAA, Traveler, and Erie are the most sensible automakers and all receive more than 4. 5 stars (out of 5) in our ratings.
The auto insurance companies for you will depend on your driving record, condition, and other individual factors. We propose buying groceries to compare car insurance quotes, as the company with the lowest rates will depend on your quick profile.
Nationwide is the go-to auto insurance company thanks to its great rates for a variety of driving records and driver ages, a wide variety of policy options, and a low level of complaints.
The national average driver rate is 29% lower than the national average. Of the corporations we evaluated, it offers the cheapest rates for drivers with bad credit, parents adding a teen driver, and drivers between the ages of 65 and 80.
USAA is the most productive auto insurance option for the military, year after year, with its consistently reasonable rates and a variety of policy options. USAA sells exclusively to members of the military, veterans, and members of your family circle. It offers a discount of up to 60% if you buy your vehicle on your deployment and up to 15% for drivers who park their vehicle at a base.
USAA’s average rate for smart drivers is 33% lower than the national average. Costs for others with speeding tickets are 34% lower and 35% lower for drivers who caused a turn of fate with injuries.
Travelers offers affordable insurance for drivers with overpricing tickets. While their rates are the cheapest, they are 19% lower than the national average for speeding drivers. We have found that the average cost of traveler insurance after an overpricing ticket is lower. than the maximum of its competitors.
Erie offers the most productive rates for drivers who have caused a twist of fate with injuries or damage to their assets. USAA is a little less expensive for both, but its policies are only available to military members, veterans, and their families.
Causing a twist of fate yields an average increase of 49% if there are injuries and 48% if there is damage to assets. Costs in Erie only increase up to 35% if you cause a twist of fate with injuries and only 29% if you cause damage to assets.
Progressive has the cheapest rates for drivers with a DUI among the corporations we analyzed. A DUI is considered a primary offense and can therefore boost your confidence. Our research found that rates increase by an average of 71% for drivers with a DUI, however, Progressive rates only increase up to 26%.
Geico offers lower rates to drivers with bad credit compared to other primary insurers. Their rates are also 36% less expensive than the national average.
Compared to other top-rated companies, Westfield offers an adequate number of discounts so family members can save on car insurance. It offers a family discount, a next-generation discount, and a puppy car insurance discount.
Auto-Owners offers new vehicle owners exceptional policy options. It offers two types of new car replacement policy and comprehensive insurance. If your new car is totaled or stolen, comprehensive insurance will pay the difference between your insurance payment and the amount you still owe on a lease or loan. Also:
Not all top-rated corporations offer new car replacement coverage, and those that do, only offer one type.
Are auto insurance companies responding to growing customer demand for a fun virtual experience?We found this out by looking at mobile app ratings and features. We found that Geico currently offers the most productive overall virtual experience among the companies that have scored well in our survey. Research of the most productive auto insurers.
Here are our top tips for finding the right company and policy for your situation.
Editor-in-Chief of Forbes
Editor-in-Chief of Forbes
Editor-in-Chief of Forbes
Editor-in-Chief of Forbes
Editor-in-Chief of Forbes
Car insurance costs an average of $2,026 per year, based on our rate research of the top auto insurance companies. That’s an average of $169 per month.
Auto insurance rates vary by state for many reasons, adding the policy limits required in the state, extreme weather situations that result in claims, and local prices for repair parts and labor.
Knowing the types of auto insurance policy that can be obtained is vital to finding the most productive policy for your specific situation. Liability is the foundation of all auto insurance policies. From there, states vary depending on what’s required, and there’s optional policy you’d possibly need for a broader policy.
To identify the most productive auto insurance companies, we evaluated companies based on their average rates for a variety of drivers, the characteristics of the policies offered, court cases opposing the company, and the collision repair ratings of body shop professionals.
Auto Insurance Rates (50% of the score): We use Quadrant Information Services’ knowledge to locate the company’s average rates for smart drivers, drivers who caused an accident, drivers with a rush ticket, drivers with a DUI, drivers with bad credit. Drivers caught without insurance, adding a teen driver, older drivers, and young drivers.
Unless otherwise specified, rates are based on a 40-year-old driver with a Toyota RAV4 and a policy of:
Car Insurance Policy Features (25% of the bill): Any car insurance company can offer the basics of liability, collision, and comprehensive policy insurance, as well as other popular offerings. But it’s also vital to have other types of policies that can offer greater policies or savings. In this category, we award issuances to corporations that offer reversal cancellation, new car replacement, disappearing deductibles, usage-based or pay-per-mile insurance, and SR-22.
Complaints (20% of score): We use complaint knowledge from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Each state’s insurance branch is responsible for recording and keeping track of court cases opposing corporations operating in their state. Most auto insurance court cases involve claims, which adds to unsatisfactory settlements. , delays, and denials.
The industry average complaint is 1. 00, so corporations with a ratio below 1. 00 have lower complaint levels.
Collision Repair (5% of score): We have incorporated corporate insurance ratings from collision repair professionals. We use the knowledge through the CRASH Network, a weekly newsletter covering the collision repair and auto insurance market segments. More than 1,100 collision repair professionals will rate auto insurers based on the quality of their collision claims service.
Auto Insurance Collision Repair Categories
Our virtual experience with ratings reflects the quality of a company’s mobile app and website. Ratings are based on:
Online Auto Insurance Quotes (40% of the score): Companies that offer auto insurance quotes on their online page earned points.
Offers a beneficial live chat (20% of the score): We give broadcasts to corporations that have a live chat (either through a user or a chatbot) that is beneficial. To measure profit, we ask, “How do I get a copy?”of my auto insurance policy?” and gave questions for a direct and beneficial answer.
Average Mobile App Score (20% of Score): We averaged the mobile app scores of Android and iOS users when there were two hundred or more reviews.
It has a useful search function (15% of the score): companies made a profit by searching for the site and displaying a useful page in the first two effects for a search on “comprehensive insurance”.
Spanish edition (5% of score): Companies got numbers by having a link to a Spanish edition on their homepages.
Here are a few other auto insurance companies that we looked at as part of our best search for auto insurance companies, but they don’t make our list of the best options.
Car insurance is a contract between you and the insurance company that gives you the policy in exchange for paying your premiums. A car insurance policy is a contract that outlines what you can claim and your obligations as a customer.
The most productive auto insurance policies cover liability (i. e. , damages you cause to others), damage to your own vehicle, and injuries caused by a twist of the car’s fate to you and your passengers.
Erie, Nationwide, Travelers and USAA all have auto insurance, according to Forbes Advisor analysis. We evaluate prices for a variety of drivers, the types of policies available, complaints, and collision maintenance to identify companies.
Drivers’ desires vary, so use our research as a starting point in your search for the auto insurance company that fits your particular situation.
The key to finding a smart deal is to get auto insurance quotes from corporations. This is the only way to know which corporations will qualify and which corporations will offer the lowest rates.
Another smart savings strategy is to bundle car insurance with some other policy, such as homeowners or renters insurance. Buy multiple policies with the same corporate effects at a decent discount.
Look for auto insurance reductions that are compatible with your motive force profile. Look for a smart reduction for driving forces if you have a smart driving record. Look for a combined reduction if you buy your home and auto insurance from the same company or from a multi-company if you have two or more cars on your policy.
There are a wide variety of auto insurance discounts presented through insurers, so ask your agent if any are missing, such as going paperless when receiving bills and insurance policies electronically for small savings. Check out the student car insurance discounts you can get if you have a young driving force in your home.
The cost of auto insurance continues its upward trend. Auto insurance rates have been rising due to new claims prices for insurers, which pass on higher prices to consumers in the form of higher rates. spare parts, labor, and medical expenses.